The Chicago White Sox have made a significant move to address their starting pitching needs, agreeing to terms with free-agent right-hander Dustin May on a three-year, $52.5 million contract, a source confirmed to the Sun-Times. The deal marks the largest free-agent outlay by the White Sox in the last four years and continues the team's pattern of adding former Milwaukee Brewers players this offseason.
May, 29, has surpassed 130 innings in each of the past two seasons after early-career injuries derailed his development. Once a celebrated Dodgers prospect, the six-foot-six righty averages nearly 97 mph with his fastball and generates above-average extension off the mound, physical tools that made him a consensus top-25 prospect ahead of the 2020 season.
Despite those impressive attributes, the on-field results have yet to match the promise. After sitting out the 2024 season recovering from Tommy John surgery, May has recorded a 4.85 ERA over the past two years while pitching for four different teams, having been traded at each of the last two midseason deadlines.
Acquired by the Brewers in August, May remained in their rotation through their World Series run but struggled down the stretch. He posted a 5.65 ERA in 36 regular-season innings after the trade and allowed seven earned runs in 11 postseason innings, including a memorable three-run homer surrendered to Shohei Ohtani in the National League Championship Series.
Left-handed hitters have exploited May to the tune of an .801 OPS over the past two seasons, and developing a more effective off-speed pitch to complement his breaking-ball-heavy repertoire is likely a priority for White Sox pitching coaches.
Key Analysis
Advanced metrics and internal evaluations are far more optimistic about May's arsenal and command than his surface results suggest. For a budget-conscious White Sox team, May represents an opportunity to acquire mid-rotation talent at a discounted price due to the absence of a full, above-average season on his resume. However, to fully capitalize on this potential coup, the White Sox must succeed in extracting standout performance from May where other respected pitching development organizations—the Brewers, Dodgers, and Red Sox—have fallen short.
May's contract ranks as the third-largest free-agent deal for a pitcher in White Sox history, trailing only Dallas Keuchel ($55.5 million) and Liam Hendriks ($54 million). He joins a rotation filled with projects and bounce-back candidates behind staff ace Sean Burke. Grant Taylor is attempting a transition from relieving, Davis Martin looks to rebound from a poor second half marred by a right calf issue, and Luis Castillo aims to redeem the final season of an even larger contract after a career-worst 2026 campaign. If the White Sox run prevention takes the step forward in 2027 that their offense managed in 2026, their pitching development will need to lead the way.
Originally reported by chicago_suntimes.
chicago_suntimes