NFL

Week 10 Fantasy Football: Emmett Johnson Shines, But Tight End Concerns Mount

Week 10 Fantasy Football: Emmett Johnson Shines, But Tight End Concerns Mount

The most anticipated fantasy storyline of Week 10 finally came to fruition: Emmett Johnson's emergence as a fantasy force. Since his first touch in Week 1, it was evident that Johnson only needed an opportunity—specifically, Kenneth Walker's absence—to become a dynamic option. The consensus that Johnson was the premier handcuff in fantasy football even led some to doubt him out of sheer contrarianism. Yet, greatness isn't a prerequisite for being a top-tier handcuff. Johnson had already demonstrated above-the-line playmaking ability, and his projected market share (30%), target share (15%), and goal-line work checked all the boxes. Additionally, the offense is built around the running back position, making Johnson a must-start when Walker sits.

For those who rostered Johnson or faced him this week, the results were decisive. Johnson amassed six receptions, 171 scrimmage yards, and two touchdowns, translating to 35.1 PPR points. That's the kind of production fantasy managers can expect whenever Walker is unavailable. While Johnson may not be a top-20 or even top-10 running back in a vacuum, with Walker out, he's a top-five fantasy back and likely no worse than RB3. Whether he's truly great remains to be seen, but the possibility can't be dismissed.

Late Games: Pickens Erupts, 49ers Roll, and Tight End Worries

The San Francisco 49ers' offense operated with ruthless efficiency against the Dallas Cowboys, racking up 580 yards on their first 54 plays before a late onside kick. However, extrapolating usage from such a lopsided game against a woeful defense is tricky. Christian McCaffrey led the team in receiving, while Deebo Samuel led in rushing—a testament to the 49ers' versatility. Brock Purdy, who entered the week third in fantasy points per game at quarterback, scored 41 points in Week 10 and continues to prove his greatness in both real and fantasy football. McCaffrey even reached 20 mph on a play for the first time since 2023, as the Cowboys' defense allowed 49ers ball carriers to run freely all day.

George Pickens, who had been disappointing all season, chose this week to explode, leaving his fantasy managers—and those facing him—in disbelief. Meanwhile, CeeDee Lamb was largely invisible until a late touchdown catch. The Los Angeles Rams' offense generated over 400 yards despite missing both starting receivers, earning praise for Matthew Stafford and the coaching staff. Blake Corum continues to be a thorn in Kyren Williams' side, vulturing work roughly once every five or six games, typically in Rams blowouts. When the game was decided, both Williams and Corum were benched, highlighting Williams' tweener status as more of an RB2 than an RB1.

In his NFL starting debut, Carson Beck was dreadful, as the Arizona Cardinals managed just 89 passing yards on 23 pass plays. If you started Jaxon Smith-Njigba, you likely felt good for most of the day—until the second half, when he exploded for an 8-171-1 line, including a 71-yard touchdown on which he fell before the pass was thrown. Fernando Mendoza was equally bad, but as a No. 1 pick, he has more leeway. The Las Vegas Raiders mustered only 98 passing yards on 35 pass plays. These rookie quarterback struggles have fantasy managers of Brock Bowers and Trey McBride deeply concerned, as both tight ends seem tethered to inexperienced passers who appear a year or more away from competence. The Raiders are comfortable with Mendoza's slow development, while the Cardinals have no veteran alternative, leaving McBride managers stuck with Beck despite his uncertain future. This was the exact fear that caused many to pass on Bowers and McBride at the top of drafts.

Early Games: A.J. Brown's Fantasy Fall, Hutchinson's Injury, and More

The Detroit Lions' dominant win over the New England Patriots in Germany came at a steep cost: Aidan Hutchinson suffered a season-ending knee injury while celebrating a sack of Drake Maye. This got me thinking about the history of celebrations, from Elmo Wright's first touchdown dance to Billy 'White Shoes' Johnson's signature move, Mark Gastineau's antics, and the eventual floodgates of first-down and team celebrations. Injuries on celebrations have happened before (most famously to kicker Martin Gramatica), but Hutchinson's is season-altering. Without him, the Lions are not contenders. The fantasy implication is that Detroit will need to go pedal-to-the-metal on offense, giving a roughly 10% bump to all skill players, but some coach must put a stop to excessive celebrations. Jahmyr Gibbs had a huge day, and Amon-Ra St. Brown finally delivered a monster game. Jared Goff played poorly but was bailed out by his teammates and a Patriots defense that couldn't tackle. Maye's injury is reportedly a multiweek high ankle sprain, and the Patriots' season is effectively over.

A.J. Brown (hamstring) exited early and is likely week-to-week, but he appears to have lost his juice and may have fallen off a cliff. A consensus top-10 receiver drafted in the first two rounds, Brown's season has been an epic fantasy bust. The Houston Texans' defense is a textbook case of regression to the mean, and unless a scheme is innovative, relying on superior players will lead to trouble. Deshaun Watson outplayed his passer rating but missed a wide-open Jerry Jeudy for a touchdown. It was a bad day for Denzel Boston and KC Concepcion managers. Quinshon Judkins had a big touchdown but didn't pop otherwise. Nico Collins was essentially the Texans' entire passing offense, which is great for his managers but seemingly bad for the team. Houston couldn't even reach 300 yards, and C.J. Stroud has now had three stinkers in the last three losses. Cross off the Texans as even a playoff contender in 2026. Additionally, Woody Marks suffered a concussion on a helmet-to-helmet hit that went unflagged.

Kirk Cousins, who historically has been a solid fantasy quarterback but not Super Bowl-caliber, performed well enough off the street for the Green Bay Packers to challenge that notion. He wasn't great, but he'll likely improve and make the Minnesota Vikings a consistent 20-to-25-point offense, which could suffice in a weak league. Justin Jefferson managers finally got tremendous market share. However, the Vikings' full-blown running back committee remains one to avoid. Cousins should be ranked in the QB12-17 range, similar to how Stafford is ranked when only Puka Nacua is healthy. The Vikings' blitzes didn't burn them against Jordan Love, who had put up big numbers in their first meeting, perhaps because Minnesota overloads to free rushers and plays zone behind it. Defensive coordinator Brian Flores should be the top head-coaching candidate this offseason.

Jacksonville Jaguars kicker Cam Little won games for fantasy managers on Sunday, and while kickers should be excised from fantasy football, Little was worth a non-last-round pick. Parker Washington, treated as just another receiver through nine weeks, exploded as the alpha against the Tennessee Titans with a 7-151-1 line on nine targets. Trevor Lawrence is the rare non-premium-round fantasy quarterback playing like an early-round quarterback for two straight years, and he'll cost you in next year's drafts. Cam Ward's play doesn't demand an extension or a move on, leaving the 1-8 Titans in no-man's land. Josh Allen had under 200 passing yards and 5 rushing yards but still scored over 20 fantasy points—he's a fantasy cheat code. James Cook earned everything he got with 157 rushing yards and a long touchdown while Allen vultured two short scores.

The New York Jets' offense aces all the quizzes but fails every test. Through Week 9, they ranked No. 1 in expected points added per play before midfield but No. 31 in plus territory and were the worst red-zone team in the league, especially relative to their skill-position talent. Cade Klubnik doesn't have an NFL arm but has wheels; he's unlikely to be the answer, but the Jets need to find out and bench Geno Smith even if healthy. Jonathan Taylor is now a committee back—borderline RB2—and it's not situationally dependent. The Indianapolis Colts managed 276 yards. The Carolina Panthers' Jalen Coker is unplayable, and it's unclear why—offensive line, injuries?—but the clock has struck midnight on his early-season Cinderella story. Chuba Hubbard was a one-man offense and did enough to hold off the New Orleans Saints, who have become infatuated with Jordyn Tyson (13 targets for 80 yards) to the detriment of their offense. Chris Olave shouldn't be getting less than a third of Tyson's targets given the rookie has barely practiced and played. This is madness.

Originally reported by theathleticuk.