Cameron Fens, a transfer from South Dakota, received a significant legal victory on Thursday as Judge Alyson Grine of the Orange County Superior Court issued a temporary restraining order that permits him to suit up for the UNC men's basketball team without delay.
The previous day, Fens had filed a motion requesting both a temporary restraining order and a preliminary injunction against the NCAA. Temporary restraining orders are characterized by their urgency and can be granted without prior notification to the opposing party.
During the morning hearing, Judge Grine sought clarification on why Fens would not qualify under the NCAA's current bylaws, which provide five academic years of eligibility. Thomas Woodrow, an attorney for the NCAA, contended that the new bylaws should not apply to Fens because he had already completed four seasons of college basketball when the rules took effect.
Fens had submitted a medical hardship waiver request in February, citing a medical misdiagnosis during his time at South Dakota, but the waiver was denied on October 20. In evaluating Fens's case, the court applied the standard for a preliminary injunction, which requires the plaintiff to show both a likelihood of success on the merits and a likelihood of irreparable harm without the injunction, or that the injunction is necessary to protect the plaintiff's rights during litigation.
Judge Grine concluded that Fens had met both criteria: he demonstrated a likelihood of success and would likely face irreparable loss if the restraining order were not issued. She also determined that his having played four seasons did not disqualify him from the NCAA's new bylaws.
In the temporary restraining order, Grine wrote, "Plaintiff has shown likelihood of success on the merits of his Fourth Cause of Action." The NCAA's Amended Bylaw 12.6 restricts eligibility to five academic years and does not include a four-season limit. Grine noted, "Nothing in Defendants' Bylaws indicates the amended rule only applies to students who have eligibility under the prior (Four-in-Five) Rule."
Furthermore, Grine pointed out that the NCAA denied Fens's request for a hardship waiver that would have restored his 2024-25 season at South Dakota. The rule stipulates that a medical hardship waiver cannot be granted if an athlete participates in more than 30 percent of games, and Grine wrote that the denial failed to consider the medical misdiagnosis and relied on a medical clearance from trainers who had not obtained imaging.
Grine also found that Fens would suffer irreparable loss of a greater magnitude than the NCAA would. She wrote, "If he is wrongly kept off the court, he will lose games in his final season that no judgment can restore." She added that Fens "will be deprived of the opportunity to demonstrate his capabilities to professional teams in competitive setting." Conversely, if Fens is wrongly allowed to play, the NCAA's injury would be minimal and unlikely to result in compensable harm.
Fens has also filed for a preliminary injunction, with a hearing scheduled for November 30 at 2 p.m. A preliminary injunction is a pre-trial court order that either stops or mandates an action by the opposing party in a lawsuit. Fens is expected to play in tomorrow's game against Marshall.
Originally reported by dailytarheel.
dailytarheel