NCAAB

Tennessee Stuns Michigan State: A Reality Check for Early-Season Overreactions

Tennessee Stuns Michigan State: A Reality Check for Early-Season Overreactions

KNOXVILLE, Tenn. — After dedicating thirty minutes to analyzing Tennessee's offensive schemes—the high pins, wide pins, duck-ins, and various other actions that had yielded insufficient results—Tom Izzo delivered a straightforward message to his squad on Tuesday morning in a Hilton Knoxville ballroom.

"Do not look at the scores of their games," he instructed regarding the Volunteers. "They will be a completely different team tonight. Every one of those guys was a great player in their conference—the best players in their conference."

Rick Barnes, Tennessee's head coach, took the opposite approach with his team: he encouraged them to trust the film and statistics about the Spartans. "I point-blank told them, 'The way they play is the way you're supposed to play,'" Barnes recounted later that night, pleased to detail how his No. 14 Volunteers defeated the No. 2 Spartans 61-46, in a game marked by historic offensive struggles.

Tennessee and Michigan State now join the ranks of teams whose early-season performances have bred confusion and contradictory outcomes. Men's college basketball has recognized the benefit of scheduling high-profile matchups early and frequently—a positive development that also increases the likelihood of embarrassing losses and heightened scrutiny.

Glitzy exhibitions kicked things off in October. Let's examine the past month of conclusions for these two programs.

Michigan State fell to UConn and at Marquette, prompting Izzo to voice significant concerns about his post play. Tennessee suffered a blowout loss to Xavier and a 39-point defeat at Duke, leading to questions about whether Barnes had overloaded his roster with high-priced, high-usage scorers (and whether Duke might go undefeated).

Then Michigan State dominated Duke in a real game at the Champions Classic and followed with a program-record 18 3-pointers, suggesting Izzo might have his best chance at a second national title in eight years—or perhaps more.

Tennessee, meanwhile, labored through three mid-major opponents, appearing far from cohesive, with chemistry concerns emerging.

Michigan State became the first AP top-2 team to make fewer than 10 field goals in a game since the shot clock was introduced in 1985, according to Nick Bateman (CBB guru).

Tennessee then suffocated Michigan State to such an extent that an encouraging offensive showing—1.034 points per possession in a 59-possession grinder, with 18 assists on 23 baskets—was largely overlooked.

Attention returned to worries about the Spartans' big men, who frequently botched coverage details and allowed DeWayne Brown II and Miles Rubin to combine for 28 points on 12-for-14 shooting.

Optimism about Barnes's team resurfaced: the belief that he will eventually get any group of young men to defend, and that the Volunteers' offensive chemistry and rhythm will develop as the season progresses, revealing a deep array of shot creators and makers by March.

And let's not even discuss Duke at this moment.

Illinois now prompts the question: Who can beat these guys? (Well, other than Texas Tech, which did so last week.) Or perhaps Houston, which handled No. 1 Florida 86-76 on Wednesday in the Players Era 8 semifinals in Las Vegas.

Sound the alarms in Gainesville.

All these high-stakes games, often between teams with vastly different lineups from a year ago, combine to create an intoxicating cocktail of overreaction.

Rewind one year. Michigan looked shaky and far from a super team in a pair of narrow escapes against Wake Forest and TCU. By Thanksgiving, everyone else was trembling. Not long after, Kentucky's NCAA Tournament hopes seemed doubtful after one of the worst losses in program history. Forget winning an NCAA game—yet that's exactly what the Wildcats did.

That's not to say Kentucky fans should feel confident about this third Mark Pope team—concern is warranted—but there's plenty of basketball left to play.

Tuesday's action before 21,678 at Thompson-Boling Arena carried more significance for the Volunteers than for the Spartans. Izzo's team jumped to a 14-4 lead and generated plenty of good looks for its best shooters for the remainder of the first half, but a night of contagious missed shots ensued.

It feels like an outlier for a team that remained No. 31 nationally in KenPom's offensive efficiency rating after the game and 43rd in 3-point accuracy (39 percent). Center is a concern, but freshman Ethan Taylor appears capable of mitigating it in the weeks and months ahead. The biggest worry is the tender right shoulder of Jordan Scott, the most important player on the team not named Jeremy Fears Jr. Scott may require extended rest.

This game mattered far more for the Volunteers, whose defense deserves greater credit for the Spartans' second-half struggles—they made things difficult for Fears and forced him into the role of shot hunter rather than his preferred role as a shot enabler.

Tennessee competed with energy and saw the ball go down a few times. Before long, it was moving as it hadn't all season, with extra passes leading to quality looks against a team that still ranks No. 4 in defensive efficiency.

"Up to this point, why would you guard our post players?" Barnes said of Brown and Rubin. "They haven't been effective. Why haven't they been effective? They haven't touched the ball."

It remains to be seen if Tennessee stays as connected next week when the Volunteers participate in the Players Era 16 tournament. Between now and the end of Thanksgiving weekend, there could be double-digit ranked-vs.-ranked matchups depending on how the brackets unfold.

Holiday advice: Feast on the hoops. Don't get drunk on the takes.

Originally reported by theathleticuk.