The pursuit of Tarik Skubal, the marquee free agent of this winter's class, began this week. Skubal and his representatives from Boras Corp. are expected to meet with interested teams in Southern California, as executives from across the league travel to make their pitches to the two-time Cy Young Award winner.
Four teams have emerged as known contenders for Skubal's services: the Los Angeles Dodgers, New York Mets, San Diego Padres, and Toronto Blue Jays. The New York Post has also reported that at least two mystery teams are in the mix, a clear indication that agent Scott Boras remains a master negotiator. Other clubs could still enter the fray, including the Baltimore Orioles, Boston Red Sox, Chicago Cubs, and even the Detroit Tigers, Skubal's former team. In truth, Skubal would be a fit for all 30 teams, but with a potential lockout looming on Dec. 1, time is of the essence.
Here's a closer look at the four legitimate contenders and how Skubal might align with their financial commitments and on-field plans.
Toronto Blue Jays
It may seem odd to suggest that a team coming off a last-place finish in its division and having traded away a longtime rotation leader in July doesn't need Skubal. However, the Blue Jays have positioned their rotation for the future, first by signing Dylan Cease to a long-term deal last winter and then by acquiring Jose Soriano from the Los Angeles Angels at the trade deadline. The development of Trey Yesavage into an above-average starter also helps. Toronto's rotation isn't crying out for a No. 1 addition the way New York's or San Diego's is. After all, only two pitchers finished ahead of Cease in this year's Cy Young voting—the two who received all the first-place votes.
Then there's the obvious: the Blue Jays finished last in scoring in 2026, last in home runs, and 28th in OPS. The offense is a more glaring need, and the lineup holes align well with what's available in a thin position-player market. Randy Arozarena had more major-league plate appearances last season than the four outfielders currently projected to comprise the Jays' outfield combined. So take that with a grain of salt. But adding Skubal undeniably makes the team much better. With Skubal and Cease at the top of the rotation (and Louis Varland closing games), the Blue Jays wouldn't need to score much to win. In the toughest division in baseball, you don't pass on the best starter to hit the market in years just because you acquired Soriano and Spencer Arrighetti at the deadline. Adding Arozarena (or Seiya Suzuki or another big bat) helps lift the team out of the AL East basement; adding Skubal brings them closer to the penthouse. Financially, José Berríos comes off the books after 2028 and Andrés Giménez after 2029, so a long-term deal for Skubal would only overlap into the 2030s with those for Cease and Vladimir Guerrero Jr.
San Diego Padres
With Michael King, Nick Pivetta, Robbie Ray, Walker Buehler, and Casey Mize all entering free agency, the Padres' rotation depth behind Joe Musgrove is thin. According to FanGraphs, the four starters listed behind Musgrove are Randy Vásquez, JP Sears, Jhony Brito, and Ryan Weiss. Yes, this club could use Tarik Skubal. The bigger question is whether new owners José E. Feliciano and Kwanza Jones will make the sort of long-term, nine-figure commitments that distinguished the late Peter Seidler. Under Seidler's watch, president of baseball operations A.J. Preller was able to pursue stars previously outside the franchise's financial reach. However, all those openings in the rotation may force Preller to buy in bulk rather than concentrate on one elite target. There are also holes among the position players, starting with the departure of first baseman Ty France, who led the club in Baseball-Reference's version of WAR in 2026. It may make more sense for Preller to pursue a reunion with King or fellow former Padre Nick Martinez rather than going long on Skubal.
New York Mets
This problem was supposed to be solved. When the Mets followed up a trip to the NLCS by landing Juan Soto for more than three-quarters of a billion dollars, they felt good about their short-term future—and their fans felt good about the guy in charge, David Stearns. However, the Mets have played below .500 since landing Soto, and Stearns' name was the subject of the wrong kind of chants in Queens last summer. While New York's woes over the last 18 months span the roster, they concentrate most in one area: the starting rotation. The rotation's collapse in 2025 cost pitching coach Jeremy Hefner his job. Its inability to right the ship in 2026 cost manager Carlos Mendoza his. If it doesn't improve in 2027, Stearns might have a clue who's next.
Since the middle of June 2025, when New York owned the sport's best record, its rotation ranks 27th in both innings pitched and ERA. Kodai Senga, Sean Manaea, and David Peterson spent large swaths of that time as essentially unpitchable. Yes, the rotation looked better over the final two months of this past season. Nolan McLean has the genuine potential to be an ace, and soon. Christian Scott and Zac Thornton are good pre-arbitration pieces. There's more help on the way from the farm. Beyond McLean, however, there's no one currently slated to start a postseason game. Adding Skubal to the top of the rotation pushes everyone down a notch into more palatable roles. Despite what the Mets are paying Soto, their finances are not in terrible shape long-term. Soto and Francisco Lindor are the only guaranteed contracts on the books beyond 2028, and McLean, Scott, and Thornton are joined by Carson Benge and A.J. Ewing as valuable pieces who won't command big salaries until the next decade.
Los Angeles Dodgers
After all that, the Dodgers didn't end up ruining baseball in 2026. The midseason acquisition of Skubal was not enough to buoy an aging club whose offseason was set adrift by the physical breakdown of Shohei Ohtani. The Dodgers were swept in the National League Championship Series by the Milwaukee Brewers, the runner-up for Skubal's services at the trade deadline. The world champion Brewers will not pursue Skubal as a free agent, but the Dodgers certainly are.
Let's run through the usual caveats: Andrew Friedman tends to prefer shorter-term agreements for players as they enter their 30s; the team is already carrying an estimated $388.4 million luxury-tax payroll into the lockout, with the sport's financial system potentially getting reshaped this winter; and the Dodgers don't really need a starting pitcher. Yes, of all these clubs, the Dodgers may have the least acute need for Skubal. The top of the rotation still includes Yoshinobu Yamamoto, Blake Snell, and Tyler Glasnow. The team is still planning to use Ohtani as a pitcher. And the club will continue to grant opportunities to Roki Sasaki. The Dodgers could run things back with that group in 2027 and not blink an eye.
But there are plenty of vulnerabilities within that group. Ohtani must prove he can remain healthy as a two-way player. Snell made only nine starts in 2026. Glasnow has a lengthy injury history. Sasaki has not earned the team's trust to start in October. So there is an obvious fit for Skubal atop the rotation alongside Yamamoto. The Dodgers could attempt to move Glasnow, who is owed $30 million for 2027, with an option for 2028 that can be triggered by the team for $30 million or by the player for $21.56 million. The Dodgers may be more interested in rebuilding their bullpen and offloading outfielder Teoscar Hernández in hopes of getting younger. Yet if the Dodgers have demonstrated anything in recent years, it is that if they can find a deal that fits their desired parameters, they will pounce.
Originally reported by theathleticuk.
theathleticuk