NHL

Rangers' Defensive Depth Creates Tough Choices as Sean Durzi Nears Return

Rangers' Defensive Depth Creates Tough Choices as Sean Durzi Nears Return

After sitting out the past eight games due to an undisclosed injury, New York Rangers defenseman Sean Durzi appears close to rejoining the lineup. Durzi participated in a full-contact jersey during Monday's optional morning skate, and with the Rangers not playing again until Sunday against the Carolina Hurricanes, that game could mark his return.

Durzi, a right-shot defenseman, was a key offseason acquisition for New York, so his comeback is undeniably positive news. However, it also presents a challenging roster puzzle for the coaching staff.

While Durzi was sidelined, the Rangers inserted righty Scott Morrow into the lineup and shifted Braden Schneider to Durzi's spot on the second pair. That adjustment has paid off, with the team winning six of its last seven games. But when Durzi is ready, someone will have to sit.

Morrow, 24, has averaged just 13:24 of ice time per game and has received sheltered minutes; his quality of offensive competition rating is the second-lowest among the team's defensemen, ahead of only Matthew Robertson, according to Hockey Stat Cards. Still, Morrow has made the most of his opportunities, recording a goal and an assist in eight games while the Rangers have outshot and outscored opponents with him on the ice at five-on-five.

Coach Mike Sullivan recently lauded the pairing of Morrow and Robertson, who has played the past five games since Albert Johansson (week-to-week) exited the lineup with an upper-body injury. "When you look at their overall 200-foot game on both sides of the puck, they've helped us on the breakouts with some of the outlet passes they make," Sullivan said. "I think Scotty Morrow, in particular, has been very effective joining the rush, helping us off the offensive blue line. He's made some plays to help us offensively, and I think they're defending hard."

Durzi's return will likely force either Morrow or Robertson out of the lineup, though Sullivan's other option would be scratching Schneider—a move that seems improbable. The coaching staff has trusted Schneider with more ice time than Morrow in all eight games they've both played, and Schneider logged 21:00 in Monday's 3-1 win over the Montreal Canadiens.

"He gives you everything he has," Sullivan said of Schneider. "It's not perfect out there, but, man, he's a competitive guy and he defends hard. I think he's a real good penalty killer, his willingness to block shots, the physical element of his game. I think he continues to develop with his puck skills and outlet passes and things of that nature, but we just love his competitive spirit. Whatever we throw at him, he embraces."

If Morrow's strong play continues, it could make the Rangers more comfortable trading Schneider—even though the organization values the 2020 first-round pick. Team president Chris Drury was already cautious about a long-term commitment last summer, signing Schneider to only a one-year deal in restricted free agency. Schneider will be an RFA again in 2027 and is no stranger to trade rumors.

The Marcus Pettersson-Schneider pairing has actually posted comparable numbers to the Pettersson-Durzi pair. In eight games without Durzi, the Rangers have a 47 percent shot share with Pettersson-Schneider on the ice at five-on-five and a 47.16 percent expected goal share, per Natural Stat Trick. With Pettersson-Durzi, those figures drop to 39.39 percent and 42.90 percent, respectively.

Sullivan could consider keeping Pettersson and Schneider together even after Durzi returns. Then again, Durzi might look rejuvenated once fully recovered from the injury that potentially hampered him before he started missing games.

To maintain three righties and three lefties in the lineup when Durzi returns, the simplest solution would be to scratch Morrow. But Sullivan has repeatedly emphasized that performance matters, and Morrow has performed well—he's held up defensively and adds puck-moving ability and offensive instinct.

If the coach were to scratch Schneider—again, unlikely—Durzi could absorb his ice time, allowing Morrow to keep his current sheltered minutes. Alternatively, if the staff wants to keep both Morrow and Schneider in the lineup, it could scratch Robertson and shift a right-shot defenseman to his off side. However, Sullivan also believes there's an advantage in today's NHL for defensemen to play their strong sides, citing their ability to make plays on their forehands, whether on retrievals, going back for pucks, or neutral-zone counters.

Necessity forced Schneider to play on the left at times last year, and it didn't go well. But that experience could also make him better prepared to handle it again. He'd also only need to handle third-pair minutes at five-on-five, then could shift back to the right in penalty-kill situations. Sullivan could also experiment with either Durzi or Morrow playing on their left.

In a broader sense, the need for the Rangers to make these decisions speaks to their bolstered defensive depth. Even if the Pettersson-Durzi pair has yet to find its footing, the group—buoyed by an elite start from Adam Fox—is in a better spot than it was a year ago. And when a team has a deep group, productive players sometimes have to sit.

Key Analysis

The Rangers' defensive depth is a double-edged sword: while it provides insurance against injuries, it also creates difficult lineup decisions. Durzi's return will test Sullivan's ability to balance performance, player development, and team chemistry. Morrow's strong play has earned him consideration, but Schneider's established role and physical style make him a trusted asset. The coaching staff must weigh short-term success against long-term roster management, especially with Schneider's contract situation looming.

Originally reported by theathleticuk.