MLB

Phillies Offseason: What Happens at Shortstop If Trea Turner Moves?

Phillies Offseason: What Happens at Shortstop If Trea Turner Moves?

The Philadelphia Phillies' 2026 campaign has concluded, and the organization now faces a critical offseason of evaluation and potential changes. The season was marked by inconsistency, as the team stumbled early before recovering to secure a playoff berth.

Given the franchise's lofty standards, a quick exit in the Wild Card Round qualifies as a major letdown. Philadelphia has now reached the postseason in five consecutive years but has been eliminated in the opening round in each of the last three. The pressure to advance deeper is mounting.

Manager Rob Thomson was already let go after the rough start, and further adjustments to the roster appear likely. The core is veteran-laden but has yet to deliver an extended October run.

Shortstop Trea Turner endured a particularly difficult year and his future with the club is uncertain. Trade scenarios and a potential position change are both on the table.

Options If Turner Moves Off Shortstop

If Philadelphia retains Turner and shifts him to the outfield, a vacancy opens at shortstop. Defense is paramount at that position, so the Phillies must have a solid contingency plan.

In free agency, Ha-seong Kim of the Atlanta Braves stands out as a prime target. Kim is regarded as the top shortstop available and would provide a reliable defensive presence.

Alternatively, the Phillies could turn to an internal solution. Aidan Miller, a highly touted prospect, had a challenging 2026 season due to a back injury that sidelined him for most of the year. However, he returned late and contributed, and he remains a talented option. Without the injury, he might have already debuted in the majors.

Ideally, Turner would remain at shortstop, but his defensive decline proved as costly as his offensive struggles. Moving him this winter will be difficult, but if a trade cannot be worked out, a shift to the outfield is a logical fallback. Fortunately, the Phillies have viable alternatives to fill the gap.

Nick Ziegler is an alumnus of the Connecticut School of Broadcasting. He has been working in sports media covering the NFL, NBA, MLB, and NHL for nearly a decade with various publications online. With his free time, Nick enjoys being at the Jersey Shore with his wife, daughter, and their golden retriever. You can follow him on X, formerly Twitter, @NickZiegler20.