NHL

Penguins' Struggles Intensify: Karlsson Trade Talk, Crosby's Future, and More

Penguins' Struggles Intensify: Karlsson Trade Talk, Crosby's Future, and More

Two decades into the 84-game season, the Pittsburgh Penguins find themselves in a precarious position. With a record of 7-11-2, they occupy 15th place in the Eastern Conference, ahead of only the Columbus Blue Jackets, who have two fewer points but also two fewer games played. The team is on pace for a mere 67 points, and their three regulation wins are better than only two other NHL teams: the Blue Jackets and the Vancouver Canucks.

Removing their 7-0 season-opening victory, which provided a misleading sense of security, the Penguins possess the NHL's fifth-worst goal differential. No matter how you analyze it, this is not a good hockey team. According to Dom Luszczyszyn's projections, their postseason odds stand at a mere 11 percent. Clearly, it is selling time for president/general manager Kyle Dubas.

Erik Karlsson: The Centerpiece of Trade Talks

The main questions loom: Who will go? When? For what? Erik Karlsson is the most obvious and probably the most prominent player who will become available. Before the season, when Dubas spoke with Karlsson, it became evident that he would not sign a new contract before becoming a free agent next summer.

Dubas and the Penguins hold Karlsson in high regard, and based on numerous conversations with the defenseman, he and his family enjoy Pittsburgh. He likes playing for the Penguins and has developed close friendships with all of the team's big names. However, the Penguins are not winning a championship anytime soon, and Karlsson, who turns 37 in May, is the fourth-oldest player on the team behind Sidney Crosby (39), Evgeni Malkin (40), and Kris Letang (39). This is a team that needs to get younger, not older.

Dubas likely can net an attractive asset or two in return for the three-time Norris Trophy winner. The big caveat: Karlsson has a full no-movement clause, so he controls everything. There are some places Karlsson would go, and others he would not. He is not likely to refuse to play in Canada, where he has already made an exorbitant amount of money and still has a home in Ottawa.

He has a reputation as a free spirit who enjoys his money, his lifestyle, and his Norris trophies, and is not all that concerned with winning. But the more one gets to know him, the more it becomes clear how badly he wants to win a championship. It means far more to him than people realize. If Dubas were to agree to a trade with a bona fide Stanley Cup contender, Karlsson would likely accept it. He knows he is not coming back to Pittsburgh next season anyway.

This cannot be how Karlsson wants it to end. He wanted the Penguins to make a final push for a championship during his years here. He says he fits like a glove with the Penguins, and, historically speaking, he does. The Penguins are known for offense, star power, and winning 7-5 instead of 2-1 because it is more fun that way. That is Karlsson. But Pittsburgh's Stanley Cup window is long closed and will not be open for quite some time. Karlsson knows it.

He likely has a list of teams he would prefer to play for, but he is not expected to make Dubas's life all that difficult when the time comes to move him. Although Karlsson has been more cavalier with the puck this season and has not reached last season's level, he is still averaging a point per game and looks as good physically as ever. There will be a significant market for his services.

Rust and Rakell on the Trade Block

Other than the injury to Bryan Rust that will keep him out for a few more weeks, nothing has changed on the Rust and Rickard Rakell trade market. Dubas is willing to move both and has been for quite some time, but he will not do so for pennies. In the Penguins' view, Rust and Rakell are good players with very favorable contracts. Neither is a rental, as each player is signed through the end of the 2027-28 season.

They can absolutely be had. Rust has no trade protection. Rakell can block a trade to just eight of the NHL's 31 other teams. It would be surprising if at least one of Rust or Rakell is not moved by the March 1 NHL trade deadline. Assuming Crosby returns next season, it would be surprising if both are moved, as the Penguins would still like to have someone to play with their captain next season.

The Big Three: Crosby, Malkin, Letang

Speaking of Crosby, what about him? The truth is, everything is in his hands. If Crosby wants to keep playing with the Penguins after this season, the team will naturally accommodate his wishes. If he wants to retire after this season, he will retire. If he wants to be traded, Dubas will trade him. Crosby has long maintained that he wishes to play for only the Penguins. Until he says otherwise, there is no point in doubting him.

He has also probably never played on a team this bad, at least not since his rookie season. He has never struggled this much in the NHL. He is on pace for 55 points. Most people spoken to within the organization believe Crosby will return to Pittsburgh next season, but no one truly knows because Crosby does not seem to know what he wants to do. These sources, as with others cited in this story, spoke on condition of anonymity to discuss sensitive internal matters.

Malkin is in a somewhat similar situation. Given who he is, the Penguins are happy to let him play out this season in Pittsburgh. If he wants to be moved, Dubas will move him. Unlike Crosby, Malkin does not have a lifetime contract in Pittsburgh.

There has long been a belief that Dubas would trade Letang if he could, but there does not appear to be any interest in him because of his declining play, contract, age, and injury history.

Prospect Progress Report

Many team sources spoken to are confused as to why Dubas has not brought 24-year-old forward Avery Hayes to Pittsburgh full time. There are a number of Hayes believers within the organization.

The Penguins know 22-year-old goaltender Sergei Murashov is going to give up the occasional bad goal, as he did in Chicago and as he did late against the Senators on Saturday. They also believe that, in time, those bad goals will become less common.

While Owen Pickering could certainly be seen in Pittsburgh at some point, there is not a feeling that he is going to have a big role in the Penguins' future. This regime did not draft him, and, with four points in 12 games this season, the 22-year-old defenseman is not playing particularly well in Wilkes-Barre this season.

Harrison Brunicke has been inconsistent while dealing with an injury, but the Penguins very much believe in the 20-year-old defenseman. They simply do not want to rush him.

Originally reported by theathleticuk.