NHL

Penguins' Penalty Kill Slipping From Last Season's Elite Form

Penguins' Penalty Kill Slipping From Last Season's Elite Form

Special teams played a pivotal role in the Pittsburgh Penguins' remarkable 2025-26 campaign, with both the power play and penalty kill ranking among the league's top ten. The power play converted at 24.1% (seventh overall), while the penalty kill operated at 81.4% (sixth overall), making both units genuine threats. Combined with strong 5-on-5 play, the Penguins relied heavily on these special teams units throughout the season.

However, through the first 20 games of the 2026-27 season, both units have struggled significantly. The power play sits 22nd in the NHL, a ranking that seems almost fortunate given how many games it has cost the team. The penalty kill ranks 13th—above average—but recent trends have been concerning. While the power play draws most of the criticism, the penalty kill's regression has flown under the radar.

Recent Breakdowns Cost Penguins

In a Nov. 8 game against the Anaheim Ducks, the penalty kill surrendered three power-play goals, including one by Cutter Gauthier immediately after the Penguins failed to convert a two-man advantage in the second period. Gauthier's goal made it 2-0, and Anaheim went on to win 5-2. A similar scenario unfolded on Nov. 3 against the Vegas Golden Knights: Pittsburgh squandered a two-man advantage late in the third period, then allowed Tomas Hertl to score the game-winning goal with less than a minute remaining. Hertl also tallied a first-period power-play goal in that contest.

The unit is not delivering in key moments as it did last year, and it is directly costing the team games. The penalty kill has been far too passive in its own zone, allowing easy zone entries and permitting opponents to set up quickly. Once the opposition establishes possession, the unit fails to apply pressure on puck carriers, allowing them to move the puck freely without resistance.

Key Analysis

While the coaching staff, led by Muse, emphasizes protecting the house and denying high-danger chances, some pressure is still necessary. Even without yielding top-tier opportunities, opponents remain skilled enough to pick corners from 20-25 feet out, especially when shots are not being blocked. Muse, a penalty kill specialist throughout his coaching career, has the expertise to correct these issues. If he can, the Penguins could regain momentum from their penalty kill and potentially secure additional wins.

Originally reported by yahoo.