Pittsburgh Penguins general manager Kyle Dubas publicly acknowledged on Wednesday what had been apparent for some time: the team is in the midst of a rebuild. Speaking at the club's practice facility in Cranberry Township, Dubas addressed the media as his squad sits near the bottom of the Eastern Conference with only three regulation wins in 20 games.
When asked what gives him hope that the season can be salvaged, Dubas outlined a broader vision for success. While a second consecutive playoff berth would be welcome, he emphasized that progress will be measured by the development of younger players, the continued effectiveness of the aging core led by captain Sidney Crosby, and the readiness of prospects acquired during his tenure to challenge for NHL roles.
Dubas then used a term he had previously avoided in public: rebuild. "This has been, I think rightfully, an unorthodox style of rebuilding a team because of the players that are here," he said. The approach aims to balance future competitiveness with preserving the legacies of Crosby, Evgeni Malkin, and Kris Letang.
Last spring's unexpected playoff appearance offered optimism that Dubas could accelerate the process, but that has given way to the reality that the current roster is a collection of disparate parts that have yet to mesh. Without officially declaring the season lost, Dubas made it clear that the group hosting St. Louis on Thursday has a limited window to demonstrate signs of life.
"If we carry on in this way, I think the types of transactions that you see from us will be very future-oriented," Dubas stated. That suggests the Penguins will explore trading prominent players who are unlikely to be part of the next contending core.
Forward Rickard Rakell and defenseman Erik Karlsson, a three-time Norris Trophy winner, are among the names most likely to be moved. Dubas declined to comment on a report that a trade sending Rakell to Chicago fell through, while Karlsson, 36 and in the final year of his contract, dismissed the speculation as expected.
"I mean I think all the speculations are pretty given," Karlsson said. "I don't think that there's anything that's coming out of the blue or anyone is really surprised about it. That was part of the reality going into this season."
That reality was something the organization hoped to delay. Yet aside from a season-opening blowout of Philadelphia—which is also off to a dreadful start—the Penguins have been one of the league's worst defensive teams. The power play, despite its star power, has been ineffective. New additions like defenseman Declan Carlile have made little impact. And while the 40-year-old Malkin has looked surprisingly spry in what could be his final season, Crosby has not been his usual self and may need a hot streak to extend his NHL record of averaging at least a point per game to 22 seasons and counting.
Informed that Dubas has no interest in short-term fixes, Crosby shrugged. "I mean, that's not really any different than it's been," said Crosby, who is 25 points away from passing Hall of Famer Ron Francis for fifth on the NHL's all-time scoring list. "I don't think that changes anything."
Perhaps not for Crosby, whose situation Dubas described as "as unique as it gets." The future Hall of Famer has yet to sign a contract extension as he weighs how much longer he wants to play. The three-time Stanley Cup champion, whose arrival in 2005 rescued the franchise, has earned the right to decide his future.
"If he wants to be here, that's great," Dubas said. Crosby has given no indication otherwise, repeatedly stating in recent months that his concern is not where he will play but for how long. He is in no rush to decide, though Dubas acknowledged that nothing lasts forever.
The Penguins have attempted to keep their championship window open while restocking the talent pipeline for the day when numbers 87, 71, and 58 hang in the rafters at PPG Paints Arena rather than appear in the starting lineup. However, they have yet to secure a transformative prospect who could accelerate the timeline—a hallmark of the franchise's success over the past 40-plus years, with a lineage from Mario Lemieux to Jaromir Jagr to Crosby and Malkin.
It has been an embarrassment of riches. Yet time is running out, not just on this season but on an era of Penguins hockey.
"Everyone's doing their best," Crosby said. "You know, we're trying to find solutions."
The problem is, those solutions may no longer be in the building.
Key Analysis
Dubas's comments signal a shift in organizational philosophy, openly embracing a rebuild while honoring the legacies of Crosby, Malkin, and Letang. The team's struggles have accelerated the timeline, and upcoming transactions will likely prioritize future assets. Crosby's contract situation adds another layer of uncertainty, as the franchise icon contemplates his playing future. The Penguins face a delicate balance between competing now and building for tomorrow, with the clock ticking on a golden generation.
Originally reported by timesobserver.