si
As the St. Louis Cardinals look ahead to 2027, the future of infielder Nolan Gorman with the organization appears increasingly uncertain. After multiple seasons of inconsistent offensive output, a fresh start might be best for both parties.
Gorman has not finished a season with a batting average above .205 since 2023. In 2026, he posted a career-low .184 average over 85 games. While his power potential is well documented, he has surpassed 20 home runs only once in his five-year MLB career, during the 2023 campaign.
St. Louis has internal options at third base, including Thomas Saggese and Blaze Jordan, and the club is also expected to explore external alternatives this winter. Ultimately, the Gorman experiment in St. Louis should come to an end—but that does not mean the Cardinals should simply release him.
Instead, the team should actively seek a trade. While Gorman's trade value is likely low at this point, acquiring something—even a low-level prospect—is preferable to receiving nothing. Gorman has two more seasons of team control remaining, and MLB Trade Rumors projects him to earn approximately $3.4 million in arbitration this winter, a modest sum that could make him an attractive buy-low candidate for other clubs.
Why a Trade Makes Sense for Both Sides
At just 26 years old, Gorman would likely draw interest from multiple teams if he were available on the open market, perhaps even on a minor league deal. His 2023 performance—27 home runs and 76 RBI in 119 games—serves as a reminder of his potential. Some team may believe they can help him recapture that form.
That is precisely why the Cardinals should attempt to flip him for a prospect. Even a lower-level prospect with upside would be a better outcome than letting him go for nothing. The organization has given Gorman ample opportunities at the major league level, and while he possesses undeniable talent, a change of scenery could benefit everyone involved.
Gorman is expected to be a popular name in trade discussions this winter leading up to the 2027 season. The Cardinals should tender him a contract and then actively search for a trade partner. It is a logical step for a team looking to move forward.