Following a commanding victory over Rutgers that halted a four-game skid, Nebraska shifts its focus to a far more formidable opponent: Ohio State, the Big Ten's most talented squad. However, this Buckeye team has not lived up to its preseason hype, making a game that once seemed like a guaranteed loss now appear winnable for the Huskers.
A seventh win would signify progress for Nebraska in the 2025 season and would also snap a decade-long losing streak against ranked opponents. Despite Ohio State's struggles, wide receiver Jeremiah Smith remains the best player on the field—and, arguably, in all of college football. Still, Nebraska coach Matt Rhule and his team have a chance to make a statement and build momentum before their Black Friday clash with Iowa.
Key Analysis
In the first game of the Glenn Thomas era, quarterback Anthony Colandrea turned in one of his strongest performances as a Husker. ESPN's QBR metric ranked it as his second-best outing of the season, behind only the North Dakota game. His overall EPA per play and success rate were also season-highs, both surpassed only against Bowling Green. Even against a weak defense, Nebraska's run-first approach helped Colandrea be more effective as a passer. In games without Rule, Colandrea was the primary source of rushing and passing production, and allowing him to focus on one aspect of the game made him more efficient at both.
Ohio State quarterback Julian Sayin got off to a torrid start this season, ranking as the fifth-best quarterback in EPA per dropback according to Game on Paper. However, the Buckeyes have been without their leader since he suffered a fourth-quarter injury against Indiana. In his place, Luke Fahey has been a significant downgrade. Fahey doesn't qualify for the leaderboards, but if he did, he'd rank 72nd in EPA per dropback (0.06) and 30th nationally in passing success rate. That's still respectable, but a far cry from Sayin, who graded as the country's second-best quarterback by success rate. A low EPA but high success rate indicates Fahey consistently makes good plays but rarely generates explosive ones. Fahey is good—anyone would be with a weapon like Jeremiah Smith—but he's no Julian Sayin.
Glenn Thomas quickly won over Nebraska fans against Rutgers by leaning heavily on the run game. The Huskers opened with a run-heavy script, and while the game situation (a big lead) favored it, Thomas called the second-most run plays in a game this season. Nebraska is unlikely to enjoy such a lead against Ohio State, but it shouldn't abandon the run. Jamal Rule is a punishing runner who becomes harder to tackle as the game wears on. The Blackshirts also need to stay fresh to contain Jeremiah Smith, especially with depth thinned by injuries. They can't be expected to defend 70+ plays as they did against Oregon. Nebraska should chew clock by running the ball and ensure its defense can still play hard late. This season, Ohio State is 1-3 when its opponent rushes for 100 yards.
Ohio State's ground game is led by Bo Jackson (no relation to the football and baseball legend). Jackson is the Buckeyes' bell cow, ranking third in the Big Ten in carries and yards. While solid by traditional metrics, advanced stats rate him lower: he ranks 140th nationally in EPA per carry and 96th in success rate (Game on Paper ranks 150 qualifying ball carriers). Defensive coordinator Rob Aurich aims to hold opponents under 3.1 yards per carry. Only one team has held Jackson to that few yards per carry—Indiana, which boasts the Big Ten's best run defense in yards per game and yards per carry. But the Blackshirts aren't far behind, holding opponents under 100 yards per game this season.
The anticipated matchup between Andrew Marshall and Jeremiah Smith was supposed to feature two potential first-round picks. However, Marshall is out for the year with a stress fracture, forcing the Blackshirts to cover Smith by committee. Danny Odem will likely handle most of the work against the superstar, but Ohio State lines Smith up across the field, giving every defensive back a chance to cover him. Odem is the Huskers' eighth-highest-ranked recruit in the 247Sports grading era. As a freshman, covering Smith will be a tall task. The Buckeyes are strong defensively, but not as strong as the Blackshirts. It will be a big challenge for Glenn Thomas in his second game calling plays. Ohio State's defense ranks in the top quarter of all college football teams in advanced metrics this season. Points may be hard to come by for both teams.
Even with Sayin's injury, Ohio State remains much more talented than Nebraska. The Blackshirts are also very shorthanded on defense, with Jahsear Whittington and Owen Chambliss joining Marshall on the injury list. The model favors Nebraska by a narrow margin, 25.3-25.0, which is within the range of home-field advantage. However, confidence is not high. The Huskers will defend well, but stopping Jeremiah Smith for an entire game is a tall ask for anyone. Ultimately, this game could end like the Indiana game for Nebraska, with the visitors making just a few more plays. Prediction: Ohio State 24, Nebraska 17.
Stay up to date on all things Huskers by bookmarking Nebraska Cornhuskers On SI, following on Twitter/X, and visiting HuskerMax.com daily.
Eric Hess is a Lincoln native and lifelong Husker fan. He founded Arbitrary Analytics in 2018 to analyze the numbers behind Nebraska sports and help fans gain a deeper understanding of the game beyond the eye test. As a graduate student at the University of Nebraska, he worked with the sports analytics department of the Nebraska Athletic Performance Lab. He began writing for Nebraska Cornhuskers on SI in 2024 and has also contributed to Husker Corner. Follow arbitanalytics.
si