Michael Irvin does not believe ESPN made a mistake in its handling of Troy Aikman—but his comment is not exactly a compliment. During an appearance on CNBC's On the Record, the Hall of Fame wide receiver revealed that he had heard rumors of ESPN's interest in moving on from Aikman long before the broadcaster's partnership with Joe Buck publicly deteriorated. Irvin declined to disclose his source.
At the time, Irvin dismissed the notion, stating that no one in the profession calls a football game better than his former quarterback. "I heard long before this—and I won't say who told me this—that [ESPN] was thinking of getting rid of Troy," Irvin told CNBC's Alex Sherman. "I shrugged it off like, 'Shut up. Get out of here. He's the best.'"
Irvin reiterated his belief, emphasizing that his opinion is not rooted in loyalty. "He is my quarterback, and he is my great friend—one of my best friends—but he's literally the best at what he does right now. Bar none. Him and Joe Buck are the best," he said. "I love Joe Buck. I know their relationship. I've been with these guys, sat with these guys, ate with these guys, and I know that they're so close. I'm so sad that it has come to this after 25 years. And I know how much loyalty and all that matters to Troy, so I'm sad that he's going through what he's going through. But he's simply the best."
While Irvin may still envision Aikman and Buck sharing meals together, their partnership this fall has shown none of the warmth he described—at least behind the scenes. The two called NFL games together at Fox for two decades before ESPN signed Aikman in 2022 and later brought in Buck, and they went more than 25 years without a hint of discord in the booth.
That ended in October, when Front Office Sports reported that the pair got into a heated argument before the Oct. 12 Bills-Rams game at SoFi Stadium. Rather than refute the report, Aikman all but confirmed it on Dallas radio a few days later, making no attempt to deny the quarrel and strongly hinting that he was preparing to leave ESPN.
It is not hard to see why Aikman might feel spurned. In September, Buck reportedly agreed to a six-year extension worth more than $100 million that locks him in through ESPN's next two Super Bowls, while Aikman is heading toward free agency in March without a serious offer from the network. Just days after Buck's deal surfaced, Aikman went on Richard Deitsch's podcast and acknowledged that his negotiations were nowhere near that far along, saying, "I thought something would be done prior to the start of this season."
The details only got worse from there. In Touch Weekly, not exactly the paper of record for sports media, claimed the argument nearly turned physical, while Puck's Dylan Byers reported that Aikman accused Buck of having "f*cked [him] over." According to Byers, Buck negotiated an early contract renewal in which ESPN proposed he might work without Aikman starting next season, and Buck reportedly would like to work with Greg Olsen if Olsen becomes available. Aikman, meanwhile, was reportedly kept in the dark for months and felt betrayed by ESPN, Buck, and their agency, CAA.
And while Irvin may still think of Aikman and Buck as inseparable, The Athletic's Andrew Marchand painted a much bleaker picture of the relationship. He reported that the conflict built up over about four years and that the two had barely spoken off the air for five weeks before SoFi. Before the argument, according to Marchand, Aikman had a tense, hour-long meeting with ESPN chairman Jimmy Pitaro about the rift and whether he and Buck had any future together. Once they were in the booth, Buck broke the silence by profanely asking whether Aikman planned to keep ignoring him, a move that sources close to Aikman told The Athletic was meant to provoke public backlash and make Buck look sympathetic. Buck insisted he wasn't the reason Aikman was still without a new contract, and Aikman reportedly answered, wounded, that he never thought Buck would do this to him.
Aikman, 59, reportedly believed Buck was behind the frequent turnover of Monday Night Football producers and directors, and ESPN went through five producers and directors before settling on Steve Ackels and Artie Kempner, a former Fox colleague of Aikman and Buck. Buck's camp has told a very different story, insisting those staffers were moved because Aikman yelled at them and that his habit of demanding specific replays made life miserable for the people in the truck. Crew members painted a similarly unflattering portrait of Aikman in 2023, telling Awful Announcing's Sean Keeley that his relationship with the Monday Night Football crew soured in Week 1 of his ESPN debut, when he complained on air that "we got a telestrator that doesn't work." They described an analyst who rarely engaged with the crew, flew home by private jet after games and knew maybe 10 of the 150-plus crew members, while Buck was described as great to work with and was said to spend time with crew members outside broadcasts.
To Irvin's point, though, ESPN has gotten a lot more out of Aikman than three hours of commentary every Monday night. The Hall of Fame quarterback also recently told Richard Deitsch that he joined ESPN in 2022 in large part to "kind of help mend the relationship with ESPN and the NFL," which had grown icy by 2016. ESPN's investigative coverage of concussions and player protests had alienated league executives at the time, and because a revolving Monday Night Football booth with Joe Tessitore, Jason Witten, Booger McFarland, and Brian Griese never lived up to the package's pedigree, the NFL saddled the network with uninspiring schedules. The Worldwide Leader began turning things around in 2021 with a new media-rights deal averaging $2.7 billion a year that brought it into the Super Bowl rotation for the first time, then lured Aikman and Buck away from Fox for more than $15 million a year apiece. The league rewarded ESPN with better games after that, and the relationship has since warmed to the point that ESPN acquired NFL Network earlier this year in exchange for giving the NFL a 10% equity stake in the network.
"Are you serious? With everything that Troy and Joe has done for ESPN when they got there, and now the NFL is giving them Super Bowls because they have real credibility after those Monday night booths they had—I think it's absolutely a bad decision," Irvin said. "It's not a mistake. That's a bad decision. There's a difference. Mistakes, you stumble along. 'I mistakenly did this.' 'I made a bad decision.' That's the difference. This is a bad decision."
ESPN has done its best to tamp down the story. Speaking at the SBJ Media Innovators conference in New York on Tuesday, Pitaro was asked by Sports Business Journal's Austin Karp about the headlines surrounding the Monday Night Football booth. He lauded Buck and Aikman's work for the network, the league, and the fans, called the recent coverage and the timing of the feud disappointing, and pointed to the previous night's broadcast as proof that the two remain professionals who can carry ESPN through its first Super Bowl. Still, ESPN has said neither broadcaster will attend Super Bowl LXI Media Day in New York on Dec. 1, which spares both of them a room full of reporters eager to ask about the feud.
And while Buck has kept off radio and podcasts altogether since the blowup surfaced, Aikman has been far more forthcoming about his future, and has even put his odds of returning to television next season at 50/50. Those 50/50 odds would have sounded absurd to Irvin when he first heard the rumor, and with Aikman's contract set to expire in March and still no new deal in sight, ESPN is running out of time to prove his initial instinct correct.
Originally reported by awfulannouncing.
awfulannouncing