yahoo
For Miami Marlins supporters, the debate often extends beyond the field: who is truly steering the ship in the front office? Is Bruce Sherman's ownership group the most inept in Major League Baseball? While labeling them the absolute worst might be a stretch—especially with occasional on-field promise—a strong argument emerges when considering the franchise's pattern of payroll slashing, poor attendance, and perpetual rebuilding cycles.
In 2017, Sherman, alongside Derek Jeter, acquired the Marlins from Jeffrey Loria for about $1.2 billion. The change was supposed to signal a new era for a club long plagued by dubious leadership, but the hoped-for transformation has yet to materialize.
Loria's reign was especially contentious. He bought the team in 2002 for roughly $158 million, with financial backing from Major League Baseball. Fifteen years later, he sold it for $1.2 billion despite persistent criticism over payroll decisions, attendance woes, and a perceived lack of commitment to winning. Sherman inherited that reputation, and his partnership with Jeter eventually soured.
In February 2022, Jeter walked away, relinquishing his 4% ownership stake. His reasoning was telling: the franchise's vision had diverged from what he had signed up to lead. That exit raised concerns about the relationship between baseball operations and ownership, particularly regarding the financial resources needed to build a contender. Sherman maintained that the organization had funds to spend, but subsequent years have not consistently shown a willingness to invest heavily in the major-league roster.
Financial Picture and Attendance Struggles
Per Forbes' 2026 valuation, the Marlins are worth approximately $1.5 billion, ranking 30th in MLB. Forbes also projected $320 million in revenue and $53 million in operating income, with player expenses at $99 million, based on the 2025 season. Meanwhile, Miami struggles to draw fans: the team ranked last in National League attendance in 2026, averaging about 15,198 per game. Winning certainly boosts attendance, but a franchise cannot expect supporters to keep investing emotionally and financially without a sustained commitment to winning.
Sherman reportedly sold a 15% stake in the franchise in 2026, generating around $232 million, with proceeds intended to reduce debt and bolster the team's financial standing. Whether that leads to increased roster spending remains uncertain.
Perhaps calling the Marlins' ownership the worst in baseball is premature. Other franchises have endured similarly frustrating ownership situations, and Miami's recent progress complicates the argument. The ideal scenario would be a multi-billionaire committed to winning and keeping the team in Miami—a dream shared by every MLB fan base. But ownership isn't measured solely by franchise valuations or operating profits; it's measured by ambition, investment, accountability, and the willingness to give fans a competitive team.
Sherman has another chance to alter the narrative; the Marlins appear closer to contention. The question is whether their owner will finally be willing to invest accordingly. Otherwise, Miami might find that changing the names in the owner's box doesn't necessarily change the story.
Originally reported by yahoo.