For the New York Mets to be genuine contenders in 2027, finding a reliable everyday first baseman must rank among their top offseason objectives.
New York entered last season without a clear long-term solution at first base after allowing homegrown star Pete Alonso to leave via free agency. The situation worsened when Jorge Polanco, who was expected to handle the position full-time in 2026, missed a significant portion of the season.
All eyes are now on the Mets to see whether they will address first base through free agency or the trade market. However, one potential trade candidate from the Boston Red Sox should be avoided at all costs.
Why Acquiring Tristan Casas Would Be a Mistake
One possible first-base option disappeared for the Mets last week when Boston signed Jake Bauers to a four-year, $58 million contract following his resurgent 2026 season with the World Series champion Milwaukee Brewers.
With Bauers expected to start at first base for the Red Sox in 2027, Jim Bowden of The Athletic reported Sunday that the club could explore trading Tristan Casas this offseason. The Mets should stay away.
Casas's time in Boston has been plagued by injuries and underwhelming performance, making it likely that his tenure with the team is over after the Bauers signing. The 26-year-old missed all of last season after suffering an intercostal strain in his left wrist while rehabbing from a ruptured patellar tendon in his left knee, which had already cut his 2025 season short.
In 2025, Casas struggled mightily, slashing just .182/.277/.303 with three home runs and 11 RBI in 29 games. He has not played since May 2, 2025, and the Red Sox have signaled it is time to move on.
While Casas did hit 24 home runs for Boston in 2023, the Mets should not even consider trading for him for obvious reasons.
Injury Concerns and Roster Fit
First is the injury bug. After Polanco played just 37 games last season due to season-ending ankle surgery, New York cannot afford to let history repeat itself in 2027 by bringing in a player with a lengthy injury history like Casas.
Consider what happened last offseason when David Stearns acquired veteran outfielder Luis Robert Jr. from the Chicago White Sox, who also had a history of injuries. It simply would not be a smart move.
Casas is also a left-handed batter, which goes against what the Mets are seeking: a right-handed bat, as they had just four last season. The Mets need an established first baseman who can play every day next season after this past season's disaster.
Tristan Casas may not cost much in a trade, but he is a first baseman the Amazins should steer clear of as the offseason rolls on.
si