NCAAF

Heisman Race Shakeup: Jeremiah Smith Back on Top, but Can He Hold Off Surging Quarterbacks?

Heisman Race Shakeup: Jeremiah Smith Back on Top, but Can He Hold Off Surging Quarterbacks?

After three weeks of slipping, Ohio State wide receiver Jeremiah Smith has reasserted himself as the frontrunner for the Heisman Trophy, thanks to a stellar showing in Week 11 of the college football season. Smith's resurgence comes after Buckeyes quarterback Julian Sayin went down with an injury on Oct. 17 against Indiana, forcing Smith to develop rapport with new QB Luke Fahey. That connection clicked in Saturday's 28-19 victory over Northwestern, and The Athletic's latest Heisman poll of writers and editors reflects Smith's renewed standing.

However, a critical question lingers: can Smith's candidacy survive if he's absent from conference-championship weekend, the final stage for contenders to impress voters? Conference titles will be decided on Dec. 4 and 5, with Heisman votes due Dec. 7. Ohio State, currently 7-3 overall and 5-2 in the Big Ten, faces a challenging path to reach the championship game for the second straight year after a four-year hiatus—and the Buckeyes don't control their own destiny. Most crucially, they must win Saturday at Nebraska and on Nov. 28 against Michigan.

On Monday, Nebraska coach Matt Rhule called Smith "undoubtedly the best player in college football" and likened him to former Alabama great Julio Jones. Still, if Smith is watching from home during the first weekend of December while quarterbacks like Miami's Darian Mensah, Utah's Devon Dampier, and Wake Forest's Gio Lopez command the spotlight, he could lose valuable support. The extent of that loss likely hinges on Smith's body of work after Ohio State's matchups with the Huskers and archrival Wolverines.

Smith made history last week, breaking the Big Ten career receiving-yardage record and setting FBS marks for most receiving touchdowns and most receiving yardage in a player's first three years. In 10 games, he ranks ninth on the Big Ten single-season leaderboard with 1,317 yards and needs 290 more to surpass Jaxon Smith-Njigba's 2021 record.

Heisman Contenders: The Top 10

1. Jeremiah Smith, Ohio State (last week: 1)
Last week: 11 catches, 117 yards, 1 TD vs. Northwestern. The Heisman favorite had his best outing since posting back-to-back 200-yard games against Illinois and Iowa. His 10-yard scoring grab from Fahey in the fourth quarter sealed the win.

2. Darian Mensah, Miami (last week: 3)
Last week: 30-for-41 passing, 382 yards, 1 TD vs. Duke. Mensah's consistency is remarkable—he was turnover-free for the eighth time in 10 games and posted his seventh outing with a completion rate above 70%. He matched every Duke score until the final minute.

3. Devon Dampier, Utah (last week: 4)
Last week: 13-for-25 passing, 204 yards, 2 TDs, 1 INT vs. Arizona. The Phoenix native has something no other candidate does: control of an undefeated offense. He added 100 rushing yards and two TDs, including a 70-yard strike to Creed Whittemore that erased Utah's fourth deficit in a 40-39 comeback win.

4. Gio Lopez, Wake Forest (last week: T7)
Last week: 14-for-25 passing, 201 yards, 1 TD vs. SMU. Beyond the gaudy numbers, Lopez is driving a juggernaut. Wake Forest led 42-0 at halftime and cruised to a 49-7 win at SMU, throttling every ACC opponent since October. Lopez also ran for two scores.

5. CJ Carr, Notre Dame (last week: 2)
Last week: 20-for-28 passing, 217 yards, 2 TDs, 1 INT vs. Boston College. A workmanlike effort for the second-year starter in a 41-7 win. Carr didn't complete a pass longer than 26 yards, and the interception was his first since Sept. 19. Only reeling SMU and a trip to Syracuse stand between the Irish and a CFP berth.

6. Nate Sheppard, Duke (last week: T7)
Last week: 16 rushes, 131 yards, 2 TDs vs. Miami. Sheppard's support held steady despite Duke's third loss. His 19 rushing TDs and 1,320 yards rank second nationally. Against Miami, he was arguably the most dynamic player on the field, adding 12 catches for 93 yards and completing two passes.

T7. Aiden Flora, Iowa State (last week: unranked)
Last week: 28 rushes, 216 yards, 3 TDs vs. Cincinnati. Six TDs and 619 yards in the past three games? That'll play for a sophomore who saw limited action a year ago. His 1,335 rushing yards lead the FBS, and the Cyclones are a surprising 5-win team. Flora also caught four passes in the 41-13 win, and his 7.2-yard rushing average ranks fourth nationally among backs with 100 carries.

T7. Malachi Toney, Miami (last week: 6)
Last week: Did not play. Despite missing the past two games, Toney remains among seven FBS receivers with 1,000 yards. His 13 TDs rank third nationally. Coach Mario Cristobal said Toney is recovering from ankle surgery ahead of schedule, and a return for the Dec. 5 ACC championship game is not out of the question.

T9. Noah Fifita, Arizona (last week: unranked)
Last week: 27-for-43 passing, 356 yards, 3 TDs, 1 INT vs. Utah. Arizona fell short, but Fifita torched Utah's secondary for his fifth straight 300-yard game. His 3,150 passing yards rank third nationally and are the most among polled quarterbacks.

T9. Carlos Hernandez, Wake Forest (last week: unranked)
Last week: 6 receptions, 94 yards, 1 TD vs. SMU. Hernandez surpassed 1,000 yards for the season with his big day against SMU. He's Lopez's top target and a dynamic 6-foot, 190-pound weapon from Alhambra, Calif. The second-year Demon Deacon began his career at Washington State. Opportunities against Georgia Tech, Duke, and possibly Miami await.

Originally reported by theathleticuk.