yahoo
CLEVELAND — The Cleveland Guardians have consistently demonstrated a fearless approach during the MLB playoffs, but their bold strategy in Game 5 of the American League Championship Series on Sunday, Oct. 18, may have cost them. For the first time, the Guardians paired starting pitcher Parker Messick with catcher Patrick Bailey rather than his usual batterymate, Austin Hedges. The result was a short outing for Messick, and the Guardians fell 3-1 to the Tampa Bay Rays at Progressive Field, now trailing 3-2 in the best-of-seven series.
Messick, who has thrown 200 innings combined in the 2026 regular season and postseason—far exceeding his previous single-season workloads in college or the minors—insisted he feels fresh. However, the decision to change catchers under the playoff spotlight did not yield positive results. The rookie lasted just two innings, allowing two runs on five hits and two walks while striking out three. He threw 57 pitches, 34 for strikes, and exited with the Guardians already behind.
Key Analysis
While the Guardians' offense managed only one run on five hits—their lowest output of the ALCS—Messick's early exit was a significant factor. The Rays' starter, Drew Rasmussen, an All-Star like Messick, delivered a strong performance, giving up one run on four hits and a walk with six strikeouts over seven innings. The contrast between the two All-Stars was stark, and it raises fair questions about the Guardians' decision to alter Messick's routine in such a critical game.
Guardians manager Stephen Vogt had previously explained that he never believed in personal catchers, but he acknowledged the natural chemistry between Messick and Hedges. After acquiring Bailey from the San Francisco Giants on May 9, the team chose to maintain the Messick-Hedges pairing throughout the season. Vogt noted, "When somebody's having a season like that, you don't necessarily want to disrupt that." Yet, before Game 5, Vogt cited Bailey's hot bat as the reason for the switch: "With the way Patty is swinging the bat, we just wanted to keep his bat in the lineup." Bailey entered the game batting .333 with two home runs and a .935 OPS in the postseason, but he went 0-for-3 in Game 5, including a double play to end the seventh inning.
Messick, for his part, refused to blame Bailey, saying, "Patrick's great. Hedgey's great. We're fortunate enough to have two great catchers. Patty did a great job with game plan. [It's] purely on me." The Guardians have a history of experimenting in the playoffs, such as starting Chase DeLauter in center field in last year's Wild Card Series despite his lack of experience there. But this latest gamble did not pay off, and fans may wonder if Vogt should have been more cautious with a rookie pitcher in a pivotal game.
Vogt defended his philosophy: "It's about trusting your people. It's about knowing your people. I work really hard to get to know these guys and what they're capable of. And what's the point of this if you're not willing to take a risk or take a chance? If you play it safe all the time, you're going to go home early. I don't think this is a huge risk putting Patty back there. He's one of the best catchers on the planet, and Parker's one of the best pitchers on the planet. So, you go trust two elite athletes to go do it." The approach is understandable, but in Game 5, it backfired. The series now shifts to Tropicana Field in St. Petersburg, Florida, for Game 6 on Monday, Oct. 19, at 8:08 p.m., with the Guardians' season on the line.
Originally reported by yahoo.