Two wide receivers who have been fantasy gold in recent years are the focus of this Week 11 start-sit debate. They aren't quite what they were, but they are still very good. The players in question are Rashee Rice of the Chiefs and Stefon Diggs of the Commanders.
When evaluating wide receivers for start-sit decisions, a few statistics that show volume and level of play are typically the starting point. Here are a variety of metrics regarding Rice in 2026: 5.1 targets per game, 4.3 receptions per game, 12.5 yards per reception, 21.2% targets per route run rate, 19.8% target share, 69% route rate, 2.20 yards per route run, 45th-ranked in PFF Receiving Grade, and 66th in EPA per Target. Interestingly, Rice's advanced metrics are average by NFL standards, but he does catch a high percentage of passes and averages solid yards per reception. That's a testament to how well Pat Mahomes has performed this season.
The matchup will help determine Rice's upside. He faces the Cardinals this week, who rank as follows with respect to Rice: 16th-most WR yards allowed per game, 7th-most WR touchdowns allowed per game, 14th-most WR fantasy points allowed per game, and 4th-most WR yards per target allowed. The matchup is quite easy for Rice. However, the game script is more concerning. The Chiefs should win comfortably, which means they could lean on the run to burn the clock in the second half. Over seven games this season, Rice has 5 red zone targets, an 11% share. This season, he has two touchdowns. You can't rely on him for touchdowns. When deciding whether we like Rice, we must focus on everything else, as stated earlier.
For Diggs, the following is the endless database that has been made for his 2026 statistics: 8.1 targets per game, 4.5 receptions per game, 10.7 yards per reception, 25.4% targets per route run rate, 23.1% target share, 76% route rate, 1.72 yards per route run, 35th-ranked in PFF Receiving Grade, and 62nd in EPA per Target. Diggs has a great usage rate. Unfortunately, he isn't catching enough balls. He has three drops in eight games, so this is chalked up to a quarterback issue that doesn't coincide with the games Marcus Mariota and Athan Kaliakmanis played. It has lingered with Jayden Daniels. Nonetheless, Diggs is the Commanders' WR1, and by advanced metrics, he is still playing quality football; not elite, but plenty good enough for top-15 wide receiver upside any given week.
Diggs is matched up against the Bengals. They rank as follows, pertaining to Diggs: 8th-fewest WR yards allowed per game, 9th-most WR touchdowns allowed per game, 9th-fewest WR fantasy points allowed per game, and 13th-fewest WR yards per target allowed. The matchup will be quite difficult for Diggs. The hope is that he sees a ton of volume, which is more likely, given the Bengals are humming on offense. My own projections see the Commanders losing by about nine points, favoring that beloved second-half 'garbage time' pass script. Diggs' red zone output is very interesting. He has seven red-zone targets this season, a 22% target share. But he has caught six of those targets and converted five touchdowns. So it's a solid value add to start Diggs this week, especially since the Bengals' sole coverage weakness is allowing 1.0 touchdowns per game to wide receivers.
Start 'Em Sit 'Em: Rashee Rice vs. Stefon Diggs
Both of these wide receivers have value, but in different ways. Rice has the better matchup, quarterback, and volume edge. However, Diggs has much higher touchdown upside than Rice and a much more favorable game script. So, who is it? There really is no great answer. It's never smart to force an answer and suggest benching a quality wide receiver. But if an 'edge' had to be awarded to anyone, it would be Diggs. His red-zone ability, combined with the game script that may ensue, gives him top-10 upside at his position. As for Rice, if you get to halftime and his volume disappears while Josh Downs and Travis Kelce benefit, fantasy managers may panic. That's the last thing we want to see with the Chiefs up two or three scores at halftime.
si