Fantasy Football Week 10: Tyler Warren vs. Isaiah Likely – Which Tight End Should You Start?

With the NFL regular season past its midpoint, fantasy managers are searching for a reliable tight end to bolster their lineups. This week's Start 'Em, Sit 'Em debate focuses on two compelling options: second-year standout Tyler Warren of the Indianapolis Colts and breakout star Isaiah Likely of the New York Giants. Both players enjoy prime matchups against defenses that have struggled to contain tight ends, making this a crucial decision for Week 10.

Tyler Warren, a Pro Bowl honoree in his rookie year, has continued to impress in his sophomore campaign. He leads the Colts with a 22% target share and has become a versatile weapon, recording 44 receptions for 486 yards and four touchdowns. Warren's 78% route participation and average of 2.1 yards per route run highlight his importance in the Indianapolis offense. In Week 10, he faces a Miami Dolphins defense that allows an average of 14.8 PPR fantasy points per game to tight ends, a bottom-five mark in the league. This favorable matchup solidifies Warren as a high-floor TE1 in Week 10 rankings.

On the other side, Isaiah Likely has emerged as a consistent fantasy contributor for the Giants, averaging 13.4 PPR points per game. He has flashed explosive upside with three games over 80 receiving yards and multiple touchdown performances. Over his last four games, Likely has commanded a 19.5% target share, demonstrating his growing role in the offense. He draws a Miami defense that concedes a league-high 74.2% completion rate to slot receivers, which bodes well for his yards-after-catch ability (5.4 YAC per reception). However, inclement weather during Thursday Night Football could dampen his ceiling.

Key Analysis

While both tight ends are strong starting options, Tyler Warren gets the nod due to his consistent target volume (7.4 targets per game over the last month) and reliable floor. Likely offers explosive upside but comes with weather-related risk. Fantasy managers should feel confident starting either player, but Warren's steady role makes him the safer choice for Week 10.