MLB

David Bednar Accepts $23.15M Qualifying Offer, Returns to Yankees as Closer for 2027

David Bednar Accepts $23.15M Qualifying Offer, Returns to Yankees as Closer for 2027

The New York Yankees received a major offseason boost on Tuesday when closer David Bednar accepted the team's $23.15 million qualifying offer, keeping him in the Bronx for the 2027 season. The announcement solidifies the back end of the bullpen and allows the front office to shift its focus to other areas of need.

Locking up Bednar was among the Yankees' top priorities this winter, and his quick acceptance represents a significant victory for the organization. With their reliable closer secured, the team can now turn its attention to external additions.

New York has several holes to address this offseason, including the bullpen, third base, second base, and catcher. Adding an outfielder, particularly a center fielder, is also under consideration.

Improving the bullpen remains the Yankees' primary objective, according to multiple reports, and that goal extends beyond simply re-signing Bednar. The team is also attempting to bring back free-agent reliever Paul Blackburn, but the next step is expected to involve bringing in external arms.

During the 2026 season, the bullpen leaned heavily on the trio of Bednar, Blackburn, and Brent Headrick, all of whom ranked among the league leaders in appearances and innings among relievers. Adding more high-leverage options would help reduce their workloads. While Bednar proved capable of recording multi-inning saves, deepening the bullpen behind him is crucial to keeping him available throughout the season.

Payroll Constraints May Push Yankees Toward Trades

Bednar's decision does create a financial hurdle. With his $23.15 million average annual value now on the books, the Yankees' luxury tax payroll is projected to exceed $300 million, just as it did last season. Given owner Hal Steinbrenner's reluctance to maintain such a high payroll and his support for a salary cap, the team is unlikely to hand out a nine-figure contract to a free agent.

As a result, the Yankees are expected to explore the trade market to fill their needs. For bullpen help, attractive options include Anthony Bender of the Marlins, Jeremiah Estrada of the Padres, and Luis Medina of the Athletics, though their availability is uncertain. San Diego could be enticed by one of New York's many starting pitching trade chips, while Miami might prefer a position player given its pitching depth.

General manager Brian Cashman has a knack for finding undervalued arms, and pitching coach Matt Blake's impressive track record of reclamation projects—with Blackburn and Headrick being recent success stories—further supports a trade-focused approach. Given the payroll situation, acquiring such arms via trade seems more likely than signing them in free agency.

Adrian Morejon: A Possible Exception?

Despite the Yankees' spending reluctance, reliever Adrian Morejon could be an exception. Both Jack Curry and Michael Kay of YES Network have identified the left-hander as a free-agent target even if Bednar re-signed. With Bednar's decision, Morejon becomes the unquestioned top relief pitcher available in free agency, putting him in line for a potential nine-figure payday—a price that might be outside New York's comfort zone.

However, since Bednar is under contract for 2027, the Yankees could use that leverage in negotiations with Morejon. The 27-year-old southpaw is considered the best setup man in baseball but may seek an opportunity to close. The Bronx Bombers could pitch him on succeeding Bednar after 2027, though given their affinity for Bednar, such a scenario is unlikely and might not be wise if they hope to retain Bednar beyond 2028.

More Moves Expected Before December 1

Even with payroll constraints, the Yankees are not expected to stop after re-signing Bednar. Securing his return early is crucial, especially as the rest of the league moves quickly before MLB's collective bargaining agreement expires on December 1. The team has multiple needs, and Bednar's return alone does not fix the bullpen. With a roster freeze looming, expect the Bronx Bombers to be extremely active in making additional upgrades over the next two weeks.