NHL

Connor Bedard's Shoulder Dilemma: Surgery or Rehab? Key Factors Behind the Decision

Connor Bedard's Shoulder Dilemma: Surgery or Rehab? Key Factors Behind the Decision

The Chicago Blackhawks' young phenom Connor Bedard is at a crossroads after re-injuring his right shoulder: should he go under the knife or attempt to rehab the injury? That's the question looming over the team and the 21-year-old forward, who has already been ruled out for the upcoming three-game road trip against the Flames, Canucks, and Kraken—and will certainly miss more time than that.

Head coach Jeff Blashill addressed the situation on Thursday, stating, "Collectively, as a group, I would say we're still gathering information, weighing the different decision processes between rehab and surgery." The team is clearly taking a cautious approach, but the clock is ticking on a decision that could shape Bedard's season and career.

Bedard has faced similar shoulder issues before. Last December, he injured his right shoulder and opted for rehab alone, returning to action in just four weeks. Then, in July, he suffered a left shoulder injury and chose surgery, which kept him out for three months. Both recoveries beat initial estimates, but the circumstances now are different.

According to Bedard's agent, Don Meehan, Dr. Peter Millett—the Colorado-based surgeon who operated on Bedard's left shoulder—recommended surgery in July because the left shoulder had sustained more damage than the right had previously. The extent of damage to the right shoulder from this latest injury remains unclear, and that's likely what Bedard and his medical team are currently assessing.

Timing is a critical factor. In July, Bedard knew most of the three-to-four-month recovery would fall in the offseason, costing him only a small portion of the regular season. This time, a similar timeline would sideline him until February or March, wiping out most of the remaining season. That reality could push him to delay surgery until after the April 10 season finale.

Key Analysis

Dr. Jorge Chahla, a sports medicine surgeon at Midwest Orthopaedics at Rush, explained on Thursday that several factors influence the surgery-versus-rehab decision after a shoulder injury. The direction of dislocation (anterior is most common), the size of the labral tear, and—most importantly—bone loss from the socket all play a role. "Bone loss is what actually makes these tears more dangerous," Chahla said. "The socket is kind of like a pear: bigger on the bottom, thinner on the top. As soon as you start losing some bone, which usually happens with multiple dislocation episodes, you start to have bigger issues with dislocating with less force." Once bone loss reaches 13.5%—and especially 20%—patients can suffer permanent reductions in range of motion, strength, or functionality. For a professional athlete like Bedard, that would be a significant concern.

Chahla noted that it typically takes multiple dislocations, not just one, to reach the 13.5% threshold, but each subsequent dislocation increases the risk of further damage. He referenced a 2017 study by Jonathan Dickens in the American Journal of Sports Medicine, which found that 90% of collegiate athletes who underwent shoulder surgery returned to play without recurrence, compared to 40% of those who only did rehab. While 40% isn't negligible, it's a stark difference. "It's a decision as to whether he wants to face some time off now vs. delaying it, playing the recovery card and seeing how far he can go," Chahla said. "Sometimes, athletes can get lucky." The same study also found that athletes who had surgery before their next season were nearly six times more likely to complete that season without recurrent shoulder instability—a finding that could influence Bedard's decision come April regarding his right shoulder. Still, Chahla clarified that even a surgically repaired shoulder isn't as strong as a normal, never-dislocated shoulder, and the risks increase regardless.

Originally reported by chicago_suntimes.