The Columbus Blue Jackets' 5-1 loss to the New York Islanders on November 17 at UBS Arena in Elmont, New York, was both predictable and revealing. It marked the Blue Jackets' fifth straight loss and their ninth defeat in their last 10 road games against the Islanders, who improved to 9-0-1 in games at UBS Arena. The predictable aspects included the lopsided score and second-year phenom Matthew Schaefer's first NHL hat trick. The revealing aspect was the listless play that has plagued Columbus for much of the season.
Nearly a quarter into the season, it's evident the Blue Jackets (7-12-0) are a bad hockey team, and the remaining 65 games loom as a daunting prospect. Any hope of replicating last season's long winning streak seems far-fetched, even with coach Rick Bowness expected to return from a medical leave that has kept him out for three games. Only two of the team's wins have come in regulation, and they have won just three of their past 30 games in regulation dating back to last season, with a goal differential of -17. Barring a dramatic turnaround, this will be the seventh consecutive year without a playoff berth, matching the franchise's longest postseason drought.
Key Analysis
The Blue Jackets' problems stem from multiple areas. The offseason was brutal, and the team lacks chemistry, often abandoning the coaching staff's defensive structure and playing as individuals. Questions linger about whether Bowness lost the locker room with his viral postgame rant about the players' tolerance for losing after last season's finale against the Washington Capitals. Players have denied it, but they haven't played with sustained fire since. The summer was further disrupted when reports surfaced that top players Zach Werenski and Kirill Marchenko wanted out.
Scoring has been a persistent issue. Two years ago, the Blue Jackets led the NHL with 16 games of six or more goals, setting a franchise record. Now they are last in the league at 2.32 goals per game and have scored just one goal in seven of 19 games. They have finished five games with two goals and are 3-9-0 when scoring two or fewer. Forwards Conor Garland, Valeri Nichushkin, and Matthew Knies, acquired as top-six forwards, have combined for only six goals, with Garland yet to score this season. Werenski and Adam Fantilli, the team's highest-paid players, have contributed just eight goals combined. Werenski scored a highlight-reel goal against the Islanders, but Fantilli saw only four shifts in the second and third periods. The Blue Jackets need Werenski and Fantilli to join Kent Johnson as consistent scorers.
Power-play opportunities are another concern. The Blue Jackets perennially rank near the bottom of the NHL in power plays, and after not receiving a single power play against the Islanders, they are last (32nd) with just 44 opportunities. They have converted six of their past 21 power plays for a 28.6% success rate, tied for seventh since October 24, but they must work harder to draw penalties by maintaining offensive zone possession and creating odd-man rushes.
Goaltending has also been inconsistent. Veteran Cam Talbot, signed on the eve of training camp as a backup, has become the top goalie, posting a 5-4-0 record with a 2.67 goals-against average and .908 save percentage. Jet Greaves, 25, who received a three-year, $5 million extension in the summer, is enduring his first prolonged NHL slump, with a 2-8-0 record, 3.42 GAA, .875 save percentage, and one shutout. Greaves has lost his past six starts since shutting out the New York Rangers on October 17. The Blue Jackets need him to improve quickly.
Finally, the absence of a captain is felt. Werenski should have the 'C' but was not given it after the summer's trade request. The plan to give him a permanent 'A' while rotating other alternates isn't working. Having a captain might not fix all the flaws, but it could raise the effort level. Werenski removed himself from consideration, but other options existed, starting with respected veteran Charlie Coyle.
Originally reported by dispatch.
dispatch