yahoo
The Arizona Cardinals suffered a discouraging 36-24 defeat to the New York Giants in Week 4, a game that showcased both encouraging signs and glaring weaknesses. While the defense and special teams delivered several positive plays, the ugly moments ultimately prevailed, underscoring the Cardinals' difficulty in making winning plays rather than allowing opponents to capitalize.
The most striking statistic from Sunday was Giants quarterback Jameis Winston's passing performance: he threw for 250 yards on 18 completions, but 166 of those yards (66.4%) came on just five plays. The remaining 13 completions accounted for only 84 yards, averaging a mere 6.5 yards per completion. Head coach Mike LaFleur emphasized the need to limit explosive plays, noting that third-and-long situations put the defense in favorable positions, but Winston's ability to extend plays and find open receivers in zone coverage led to breakdowns. LaFleur acknowledged the need to review the tape and address these issues swiftly.
The defense also suffered a significant loss when safety Andrew Wingard exited in the first quarter with a knee injury after recording one solo tackle. Wingard had been productive in the first three games, tallying 22 tackles (nine solo, three for loss), an interception, and a forced fumble. With Dadrion Taylor-Demerson inactive due to a back injury, rookie undrafted free agent Wydett Williams Jr. saw increased playing time.
Defensive Highlights
Despite the setbacks, the run defense performed admirably. The Cardinals limited running back Cam Skattebo to 58 yards on 18 carries (3.2 average) and Najee Harris to 30 yards on nine attempts (3.3 average). Tyrone Tracy added one carry for minus-1 yard, resulting in the Giants' ground game managing only 87 yards on 28 attempts (3.1 average), with long runs of nine yards for Harris and eight for Skattebo. The defense recorded seven tackles for loss, led by Walter Nolen III with two.
The takeaway department also showed promise. Safety Budda Baker intercepted a poor Winston pass in the third quarter, leading to a Cardinals touchdown and a 24-19 lead. Cornerback Denzel Burke read a route late in the second quarter and picked off a pass intended for rookie wide receiver Malachi Fields at the Cardinals' 25-yard line, setting up a 60-yard Chad Ryland field goal as time expired in the first half. Linebacker Mack Wilson Sr. forced a fumble from Harris that Zaven Collins recovered, but the offense failed to capitalize, going three-and-out during a stretch of three consecutive punts in the fourth quarter.
The Ugly Breakdowns
The ugly moments were plentiful, none more glaring than a 40-yard pass to a wide-open Fields on third-and-20 from the Giants' 42-yard line in the third quarter. That drive began with a 28-yard pass to wide receiver Malik Nabers, who later scored on a 25-yard play to give the Giants their first lead in the second quarter. Nabers finished with six catches on seven targets for 112 yards (18.7 average). Notably, Nabers was selected two picks after Marvin Harrison Jr. in the 2024 draft.
After the 40-yard play, the Cardinals appeared to have held the Giants to a field goal, but defensive lineman Dante Stills was flagged for holding on the attempt, granting a first down. Two plays later, the Giants scored a touchdown and converted a two-point try to take a 27-24 lead. Stills was furious and called it a poor call. LaFleur said the explanation was that they jerked the guy, and while he didn't see it from the sideline, if it happened, it can't be done. CBS-TV rules analyst Gene Steratore said it was the right call because Stills slightly grabbed blocker Aaron Stinnie's jersey, allowing linebacker Jordan Burch to shoot through the gap.
Special teams also contributed to the ugliness. Tracy had a 55-yard kickoff return in the first quarter that led to a Giants 50-yard field goal after the Cardinals had taken a 14-3 lead. New York's first field goal came after a 39-yard pass to Nabers on third-and-12, and tight end Isaiah Likely gained 34 yards on a third-and-4 pass. Punter Blake Gillikin averaged a pedestrian 43.2 yards gross and 38.7 net on six punts, including two consecutive 37-yarders that set up a Giants touchdown. Kickoff returner Devin Duvernay had a 39-yard return to open the game but inexplicably allowed a punt to bounce at the 15-yard line in the fourth quarter instead of fair catching it; the ball was downed at the 3. After a 44-yard Gillikin punt was fair caught at midfield, the Giants drove to the Cardinals' 34 and kicked a 52-yard field goal to take a 30-24 lead.
Entering the game, Gillikin was averaging 46.3 yards gross and 39.4 net. In five games before a back injury ended his 2025 season, he averaged 51.7 yards gross and 45.4 net. He was hampered by a groin injury in training camp this year.
For more Cardinals and NFL coverage, listen to the Rise Up, See Red podcast, available on Spotify, YouTube, or Apple Podcasts.
Originally reported by yahoo.