Unless the two sides can reach an agreement—an outcome that appears unlikely—Major League Baseball will enter a player lockout at 12:01 a.m. on Dec. 2, immediately after the current Collective Bargaining Agreement expires at 11:59 p.m. on Dec. 1. During the lockout, teams will be prohibited from signing free agents or completing trades involving any player on the 40-man roster, and players will be barred from team facilities, including those rehabilitating injuries.
Because players are paid only during the season, they will not miss paychecks during the lockout, though signing bonuses and deferred money will still be paid. However, if the work stoppage extends into late March, when the season is scheduled to begin, players will not be paid. Tuesday marked the deadline for free agents to accept or decline qualifying offers, opening a window that could see a rush of signings before the lockout starts. In November 2021, before the most recent lockout, teams committed more than $1.9 billion to free agents, with $1.4 billion spent on Dec. 1 alone.
The impasse between owners and players centers on the salary cap. Owners want one; players do not. MLB is the only one of the four major North American sports leagues without a salary cap. The NFL operates under a hard cap, while the NBA and NHL use soft caps. The key distinction is whether teams may exceed the spending limit: a hard cap is an absolute ceiling that cannot be crossed under any circumstances, while a soft cap permits teams to go over the limit through specific rules and exceptions.
MLB owners are proposing a hard cap of $258.2 million as the maximum a team can spend on player salaries, along with a $180.2 million floor as the minimum. Commissioner Rob Manfred and the owners' labor committee contend that such a system would provide small- and mid-market teams with the certainty needed to compete consistently. According to Sports Business Journal, owners might eventually accuse the players of failing to negotiate in good faith, declare a bargaining impasse, and attempt to impose their last offer—a move that would likely be met with strong resistance from the players association. Observers believe only a significant break within the MLB Players Association would compel it to accept any form of salary cap.
The players' position is clear: a cap would limit what players can earn compared to the current CBA. They also point to the 2026 playoffs, where three of the final four teams—including the champion Milwaukee Brewers and runner-up Tampa Bay Rays—were in the bottom half of league payrolls, as proof that a salary cap is not necessary to achieve parity. The association argues that owners want a cap to inflate franchise values.
It has also been reported that the players association could respond to a protracted lockout with its nuclear option: filing a disclaimer of interest, a formal declaration by a union that it no longer wishes to represent a specific group of workers in collective bargaining. This would allow players to sue owners for antitrust violations. Ultimately, it could strip MLB owners of the nonstatutory labor exemption—the judicial doctrine that shields collectively bargained work rules and lockouts from antitrust scrutiny. Players could then argue that an owner-imposed lockout outside of a collective bargaining agreement constitutes an illegal group boycott under the Sherman Antitrust Act. A player victory on this point could expose MLB teams to billions in potential triple damages for lost salaries and revenue during a work stoppage, creating immense financial pressure on owners to return to the bargaining table.
Key Analysis
Several other issues will be addressed in negotiations. Owners have offered earlier free agency for players age 30 and older, with a five-year limit on contracts. Players want to reduce the six-year service-time requirement for free-agent eligibility to five years or an age cutoff so that younger stars reach free agency in their prime. Players also seek a higher minimum salary. Ultimately, however, the salary cap will determine the outcome, and both sides are currently dug in.
Serious negotiations are not expected to begin before mid-January, given that pitchers and catchers are scheduled to report for spring training on Feb. 9 and a settlement must be reached by March 15 for a full season to be played. A prolonged lockout could very well impact the season, and some are even questioning whether there will be a season at all. The Mets are scheduled to open the 2027 season on the road against the Florida Marlins on Thursday, March 25. One observer expressed hope that in 126 days, they will be watching on TV as the Mets defeat the Marlins.
Tom Kirkpatrick Sr. is a Silver Creek resident. Send comments to [email protected].