NFL

Arch Manning: The Quarterback Everyone Can't Stop Talking About

Arch Manning: The Quarterback Everyone Can't Stop Talking About

This column is part of the problem. It contains no new noteworthy nuggets about Arch Manning, nor does it offer any earthshaking observations about his performance as quarterback of the Texas Longhorns. But here it is anyway, because this is America. In this country, every citizen is constitutionally required to announce at least one loud Manning opinion per week. If you doubt that, we would encourage you to look it up for yourself on the internet, except these days there is a good chance the internet won't be working when you try, so you'll just have to trust us.

Yes, there probably are lots of subjects in the world infinitely more interesting than whether or not Manning is absurdly overrated or weirdly underrated, and you might even think it's not your place to make such judgments. But rules are rules, and nobody is exempt. Not even government officials. Tuesday morning, during an interview on a national financial news network about the Federal Aviation Administration's national ground stop that stranded travelers at hundreds of airports over the weekend, Homeland Security Secretary and noted college football enthusiast Markwayne Mullin was asked to weigh in on the most pressing issue of our time. "You think Arch Manning should start doing some of this stuff earlier?" CNBC's Joe Kernen asked the man nominally in charge of our country's counterterrorism efforts, and as much as you might want to believe that we are making that up to prove a point, we regret to inform you that we are not.

Now, it should be acknowledged here that Manning asked for none of this. He did not ask for the hype and fanfare that came with having a Pro Bowl grandfather and two Super Bowl-winning uncles. He did not ask to be anointed as a Heisman Trophy favorite before his first season as a college starter. And he did not ask to become ratings gold for every debate show under the sun. In fact, Manning has spent most of his four years at Texas going out of his way to be as intentionally boring as possible during interviews, save for the one time he made the baffling decision to bring up and chuckle at a tasteless video in front of reporters. That, of course, ignited a multi-day news cycle of Manning stories and Manning hot takes, but it seems like we get one of those cycles every week.

In this regard, he might be unlike any college football player the sport ever has seen. At least back in the day when Texas A&M's Johnny Manziel took the internet by storm as Johnny Football, it was because he was compelling. He played quarterback compellingly. He celebrated compellingly. He got into off-field mischief compellingly. Manning does none of that. This is not to say that he is a bad quarterback, or even one incapable of leading his team to a national championship, but there is nothing singularly spectacular about his game. He can throw an NFL-caliber deep ball every now and then. He can be prone to bafflingly poor decision-making at times. This tends to drive Longhorn fans crazy, but they are far from alone there.

"Talented guy who looks like a first-rounder at times but battles inconsistency" describes the quarterback at approximately two or three dozen programs in college football. The difference is that every Manning mistake gets scrutinized to death, even when he's running for his life behind an overmatched offensive line. And every Manning success turns him into the second coming of Vince Young, even if all he did was hit a running back in stride at the line of scrimmage Saturday on a game-winning swing pass at LSU. A couple of days later, Manning made more headlines by confirming he will participate in senior day festivities at Royal-Memorial Stadium this Saturday, which would be a run of the mill dog-bites-man story except for the fact that he has a year of college eligibility remaining. Choosing to be honored with his fellow seniors does not mean Manning will go pro this offseason. Nor does it mean that he won't come back for a fifth year with the Longhorns. Nor does it mean that he won't transfer to another college program for that fifth year. His options remain open. In the meantime, in the case of the People vs. Arch, we await an official ruling from the U.S. Supreme Court. We'll get it as soon as the internet starts working again.

Key Analysis

The intense scrutiny surrounding Arch Manning highlights a broader phenomenon in sports media where hype and lineage can overshadow actual performance. Manning's situation is unique because he hasn't asked for the attention, yet every move he makes is dissected. This constant debate reflects the public's insatiable appetite for narratives, even when there's little substance to add. As Manning navigates his college career, the opinions will keep coming, for better or worse.

Originally reported by yahoo.