yahoo
The College Football Playoff selection committee is under fire for placing Alabama at No. 5 in its initial rankings of the season, a decision that has fans crying foul over SEC favoritism and questioning the committee's credibility.
Critics are baffled by how Kalen DeBoer's squad landed eight spots ahead of Tennessee, a team that convincingly defeated Alabama 26-10 in Knoxville on Oct. 17 and holds the same 6-2 record. Social media erupted with indignation, and not of the Crimson variety.
"Alabama has pictures of somebody," On3's Blain Crain posted on X, laughing. Chris Marler opined, "There is nothing Alabama has put on the field in the last three weeks that says they are a Top 5 team dawg." Brandon Walker of Barstool Sports called the ranking "one of the most stunning things I've ever seen" and dismissed SEC bias, arguing that at least three SEC teams should be ranked above the Tide. "In no way should they be above Ole Miss or Texas," he added. Former Florida State star quarterback Danny Kanell labeled the committee "the worst, most non-sensical one yet," pointing out that Tennessee's two losses are by a field goal or less, yet the Volunteers are ranked No. 13 while Alabama sits at No. 5.
While the outrage is understandable, analysts may be overlooking Alabama's credentials and the context of their performances. The Crimson Tide boast a 45-17 road win over now-No. 6 Kentucky, a 49-18 victory against a South Carolina team that has since entered the CFP rankings, and a 56-23 thrashing of Mississippi State. Their 20-17 home loss to Georgia was marred by controversy and deserves scrutiny. The Tide dealt with injuries against Tennessee, but that does not excuse the loss—the Volunteers simply outplayed them. However, Tennessee just lost to South Carolina, so the situation is far from black and white.
Key Analysis
What is clear is that Alabama has no losses to teams outside the current CFP top 15. Texas fell to Florida and Oklahoma, undefeated UCLA's best win came against a Dante Moore-less Oregon (or Wisconsin), BYU lost to a .500 UCF team, and Ole Miss was decimated by Florida in The Swamp. Do the media and fans truly despise the No. 5 ranking, or is the unprecedented parity in college football rattling everyone? If the Crimson Tide stumble at LSU on Saturday or falter in the Iron Bowl on Nov. 28, the committee will face immense pressure to penalize them severely. Alabama has the power to avoid that dilemma, starting with their upcoming clash against LSU.
Originally reported by yahoo.