1) What the (public) models predicted (collected sources)
I searched five reputable model/prediction sources that publish game forecasts or computer predictions for MLB:
-
AP / ESPN (computer projection) — projected Dodgers 5, Phillies 4.
-
Fox Sports preview — projected Dodgers 5, Phillies 4.
-
ATS.io (model projection) — projected Dodgers 4, Phillies 3 (Dodgers by 1).
-
OddsShark / Odds aggregation (numerical predicted split) — effectively projects 4.5–4.5 (a toss-up near a 4–5 total each).
-
BetQL / Action Network / SportsLine — these sites published picks/edges for the matchup (some content behind paywalls), with BetQL/ActionNet showing value signals for Philadelphia in places and SportsLine publishing an expert forecast page for the game. (I captured their published picks/indications even when a full numeric score was paywalled).
(Notes: some commercial services keep full numeric forecasts behind subscriptions — I used the public projections, computer forecasts and published numeric score predictions where available.)
2) Averaging the published numeric score predictions
From the sources above that published numeric scores I averaged the finals:
-
AP/ESPN/Fox → Dodgers 5 / Phillies 4 (three identical forecasts)
-
ATS.io → Dodgers 4 / Phillies 3
-
OddsShark → Dodgers 4.5 / Phillies 4.5
Averaging those five numerical forecasts gives:
-
Average projected score (models) ≈ Dodgers 4.7, Phillies 3.9 → round to Dodgers 5, Phillies 4.
So the consensus model call was a one-run Dodgers win (close game, total ≈ 9).
3) My independent analysis (Pythagorean + SOS + starters + injuries + trends)
A. Season-level baseline (Pythagorean)
Key season rates (team runs per game & runs allowed per game from StatMuse / team stat pages):
-
Dodgers runs scored ≈ 5.11 r/g, runs allowed ≈ 4.31 r/g.
-
Phillies runs scored ≈ 4.86 r/g, runs allowed ≈ ~4.01 r/g.
Using a simple Pythagorean formula (win% ≈ RS² / (RS² + RA²):
-
Dodgers Pythagorean win% ≈ 58.4%.
-
Phillies Pythagorean win% ≈ 59.5%.
Interpretation: on run-differential form across the season, both teams look quite strong and the Pythagorean check actually gives Philadelphia a very slight edge (their run differential / pitching mix is slightly better in the aggregate). (Calculation shown in my reasoning.)
B. Starting pitchers & direct matchup (big adjustment)
Probable starters (published game info):
-
Philadelphia: Cristopher Sanchez — very strong 2025 season (example: 13–5, ERA ~2.57, big K total).
-
Los Angeles: Shohei Ohtani — elite bat, usable as starter this season but lower IP volume and he’s at a higher ERA (3.75) vs Sanchez.
Matchup effect: Sanchez (season-long front-line performance, LHP) against a Dodger lineup is a favorable neutralizer; Ohtani is a big run producer from the Dodgers lineup but has less starting innings and is not as dominant this year as an ace with Sanchez’s season numbers. This matchup is a point in the Phillies’ favor for the single game.
C. Recent trends & roster health
-
Philadelphia: red-hot stretch into September (reports show long winning runs — Reuters/AP note Phillies were 14–4 since Aug 28 pregame and clinched NL East in this game). But they also had notable injuries (Trea Turner, Alec Bohm, Zack Wheeler noted as injured earlier in season reporting).
-
Los Angeles: strong offense (high r/g) and the home park (Dodger Stadium) generally helps run scoring, but some bullpen issues and injuries (catcher Will Smith on IL noted in injury list).
D. Strength of Schedule (SOS)
-
Both teams have had heavy slates versus good opponents; Phillies’ recent run includes beating strong opponents — that strengthens my trust in their short-term form. Dodgers have faced tough NL West competition. On balance, SOS doesn’t swing heavily away from Philadelphia.
E. Putting it together (my pregame forecast)
-
Pythagorean season baseline: slight Phillies edge.
-
Starter matchup (Sanchez vs Ohtani): leans Phillies.
-
Home field and Dodger lineup/park power: leans Dodgers.
-
Recent form: leans Phillies.
-
Injuries: roughly balanced (both have some IL players), but Phillies’ depth has been tested and still performing.
My independent game score projection (pre-game):
-
Philadelphia Phillies 5 — Los Angeles Dodgers 4 (Phillies by 1).
My win-probability estimate (pre-game): Phillies ~52%, Dodgers ~48% — I treat this as a close tossup but with modest value on Philly +113. (I emphasize: this is the pregame analytic result.)
4) News & breaking updates (important — changed the picture)
While assembling the above, I confirmed breaking news (game result): the Phillies won this game, 6–5 in 10 innings, clinching the NL East in dramatic fashion (J.T. Realmuto sacrifice fly in the 10th). That outcome validates the value case on Philadelphia and shows the game was indeed close and high scoring. Sources: Reuters & AP. So the actual final result: Phillies 6, Dodgers 5 (10 innings).
